Co-Op City Not Cooperating, Say Regulators

WNYC News | Jun 30, 2015

The board of Co-Op City has been warned by regulators that it's entering a crisis of its own making. The massive Bronx housing complex could default on its debts, but for an unusual reason that has nothing to do with failure to pay.

Instead, Co-Op City could enter a “non-monetary default,” for not abiding by the terms of a $621.5 million loan.

That 2012 loan from Wells Fargo included language requiring the Co-Op City board to hire a professional outside managing agent to look after the property. The loan was jointly insured by the Department of Housing and Urban Development and the New York State Division of Homes and Community Renewal

But last November, Co-Op City's board fired its managing agent, and the board has been “self-managing” since then.

Inside the complex, views on what to do next are sharply split.

“This is a big place. We are a city in ourself, right? So if I have a full time job, how can I run a city?” said Toni, who didn’t want her last name used.

But Toni’s neighbor, Joan McKay, believes self-management actually works better.

“The last management company we had, we paid them millions every year, all it did was increase our carrying charges, and decrease our services,” McKay said.

Daryl Johnson, a board member, said three management companies have made presentations to the board. While Johnson favors signing a contract soon, the majority, he said, prefer self-management.  

Last month, HCR Deputy Counsel Mark Colón sent the Co-Op City board a letter stating that that an outside managing agent must be hired by June 30th, or the lender may seek "all appropriate remedies."

An HCR spokesperson would not say precisely what that means. Inaction by the board could conceivably lead a lawsuit, or regulators replacing some board members, or overriding the board to hire a manager.

A lawyer for the board, Jeffrey Buss, said he's asked the HUD and HCR to meet with the board, to try to reach an agreement to avoid a default.

Be alert for scams. WNYC never asks for nor accepts money for coverage or interviews. Anyone making such a request does not represent WNYC.

Top Stories

Mamdani lays out plan to close Rikers by 2032, after years of delays

Why It Seems Like Everything Is Breaking

The ICE Flight Tracker

Advice for Deciding Whether to Have a Kid

YOU ARE ONLINE