Diane Arbus: A Rare Interview

Diane Arbus in Central Park, 1969 by Garry Winograd (printed 1983)

Diane Arbus, whose indelible black and white portraits of people— strippers, circus performers, a Jewish giant towering over his parents, random New Yorkers she encountered in the street, babies (including broadcast journalist Anderson Cooper), nudists, the LGBTQIA+ community—have become classics of documentary photography, would have turned 100 this year.

Fifty-two years after her death, WNYC Archives revisits a rare interview with Arbus, who discusses her thoughts about women’s liberation, how she chooses her subjects, sex, and being a mother to two young daughters. Very few recordings of Arbus exist.

Arthur Lubow, author of the comprehensive biography, Diane Arbus: Portrait of a Photographer, wrote in an email that “Arbus's voice—both her way of putting things and her whispery girlish sound—was unique. And her vision as expressed in words was totally consistent with the way she depicted the world in photographs. I have heard only two of her recorded talks. The discovery of a third is a real find."

Arbus’s two daughters, Amy, now 69 and a photographer, and Doon, 78, a writer who manages her mother’s estate, did not respond to requests for comment.

Diane Arbus was one of 80 women interviewed for Viewpoints of Women hosted by WNYC Program Director Richard Pyatt in January or February 1971. To date, the episode with Arbus is the only one that exists from this series that included women discussing their work and their roles in society.

Arbus’s conversation was recorded at WNYC’s 25th-floor studios in Manhattan’s Municipal Building, a short bike ride from her apartment at Westbeth Artists Housing in the West Village.

At that time, Arbus was struggling to pay her rent, recovering from two bouts of hepatitis, and living with depression. Four months after the WNYC program was broadcast in March, she would take her own life at the age of 48 in July 1971.

Pyatt calls Arbus “adventurous and mysterious.” Sounding shy and perhaps bored with the same questions women are still being asked today, Arbus quietly holds her own against Pyatt’s sonorous voice and probing questions. 

Diane Arbus: Of course, I think that men have problems, too.

Richard Pyatt: That's a known fact.

Diane Arbus: You wanna tell me your problems?

In a dialogue filled with stops, starts, and silences, Pyatt, then 42, called journalism “a man's world, that politics is a man's world, that this is a man's world, and photography has more or less been considered a man's world. He asks, “Is that a part of the environment that you've become accustomed to, Diane Arbus?”

Arbus’s mentor was Lisette Model, renowned for her street photography and portraiture, who later went on to teach at The New School for Social Research. Arbus was her most famous pupil. There has never been a shortage of great women photographers: Julia Margaret Cameron, Berenice Abbott, Dorothea Lange, Lee Miller, Margaret Bourke-White, Mary Ellen Mark. Helen Levitt, Lisa Larsen, Imogen Cunningham, Ilse Bing, Florestine Perrault Collins, Lola Álvarez Bravo, Tina Modotti, and others who hadn’t received the same recognition or assignments as their male counterparts back then, and even today.

Arbus quietly rebuffs Pyatt. “There have always been women photographers … very good ones … ” she says.

In this 25-minute interview, Pyatt attempts to pin down Arbus’s groundbreaking raw style and asks if there was a particular type of subject or story that she seeks. Her most well-known images include a grimacing boy clutching a toy hand grenade, twin sisters dressed in matching black dresses and white collars, and a man in hair rollers holding a cigarette.

Richard Pyatt: You just walk down the street and take pictures of anything?

Diane Arbus: No, not usually, although sometimes I do that. Now I'm very interested in the differencesSome of these differences areEverybody's got two eyes, a nose, and a mouth. But there are these incredible variations on that theme, also on the nature of the person, what they choose in the way of what they wear, what their role is in—you know, what their work is, how rich and how poor, what their sort of social, intellectual sort of general position is,certain attitudes or something like that, or a lot of this is visual.

Richard Pyatt: So that before you actually take a picture, a lot of this introspective analysis goes on in your mind.

Diane Arbus: I don't think it's analysis, but it's an encounter, right? Sometimes I don't talk to the person at all. But there's some kind of element ofthis other experience, this other sort of world, and this other sort of milieuI like people who are not like me. I like even people I don't like.

This was 1971. A woman could not have a credit card in her own name and was not permitted to fight on the front lines in the military. A woman could be fired if she became pregnant. Spousal rape wasn’t outlawed until 1993. A woman couldn’t sue for sexual harassment and could be charged more for health insurance than men. Women were paid, on average, 57 cents to every dollar that men earned.

Richard Pyatt: What would you consider to be the greatest problem in being a woman today?

Diane Arbus: Today.

Richard Pyatt: Or what would you consider to be the most enjoyable thing about being a woman?

Diane Arbus: I think sexual freedom is very enjoyableThe woman part of it is sort of terrific fun 'cause women have a lot more power now sexually in the first place, but that sort of spills overit's important. Just the sense that women can now experience the same variety as men have traditionally experienced I think sex is very educational.

Richard Pyatt: That sex is educational and that women are absolutely different from men. Their chromosomes in every cell of their body—

Diane Arbus: Oh, really?

Richard Pyatt: is absolutely different from that of the male, which makes them an entirely unique and different animal.

Diane Arbus: I've always been interested in the differences between women and men…For instance, there are women photographers and men photographers of women's pictures. I don't thinkit's a theme you should hammer on too long.

Richard Pyatt: We have about a moment, and in that moment, let me ask you a question regarding your work. Does your attitude change when you photograph a man, uh, a male or, or a female? Or you’re not influenced by that at all?

Diane Arbus: Oh, I think I'm influenced by everythingI think it's very deep in you.

Her work, biographer Patricia Bosworth wrote in her book Diane Arbus: A Biography, was “both damned for its voyeurism and praised for its compassion … She deliberately explored the visual ambiguity of people on the fringe and at the center of society.”

Finally, in 2018, Diane Arbus’s obituary appeared in the new Overlooked section of The New York Times. Written by James Estrin, he concludes that “After decades of intense examination of her work and life, perhaps there is room to understand Arbus as a woman driven by artistic vision as well as personal compulsion, and her photographs as documents of empathy as well as exploitation.”

Much of what Arbus divulges in the WNYC interview isn’t a secret. Her life and work have been analyzed and psychoanalyzed many times over.  Her provocative work influences photographers today, including the intensely personal photographs of Nan Goldin and Cindy Sherman.

Arbus’s photographs continue to fascinate. An Instagram account of her work tops 83,000 followers.  Diane Arbus: 10 Years opens at the Susquehanna Art Museum in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, on September 30 and runs through January 21, 2024.  Diane Arbus: Constellation honors the centenary of her birth with the largest exhibit of her work—454 images including rare and unseen photographs— on view at the Luma Foundation in Arles, France through April 30, 2024.

A photograph is a secret about a secret,” Arbus wrote in Artforum magazine in 1971. “The more it tells you the less you know.”

_______________________________________

Special thanks to the Duke University Special Collections for making this audio available to us.