Harlem Residents Push Back Against Opioid Clinics After Data Shows Most Are Used By Non-Residents

A small group of Harlem residents protested a new overdose prevention center that opened in the neighborhood on December 11. Most said they supported the center's harm reduction mission but worried Ha

Anne-Karine Dabo, a mother of a two-year-old who moved to Harlem three years ago, began avoiding the playground at Marcus Garvey Park last year. The intersection of 125th Street and Lenox Avenue came next. Soon, she was finding alternate routes around her own neighborhood.

"It was more than just seeing people who were high. It was seeing people who looked dead," she said.

At first, she regularly called 911 to help drug users in distress but stopped when it became commonplace shortly before the pandemic began. Dabo said the neighborhood has rapidly changed for the worse, and that the uneven distribution of opioid treatment programs across the city is to blame.

For decades, Harlem residents have voiced concerns that their neighborhood has been a too-convenient location to place social services, like shelters and addiction programs, that other neighborhoods fight hard to keep out. This past weekend, Rev. Al Sharpton and U.S. Rep. Adriano Espaillat led a protest against a newly installed supervised injection site in Harlem, the first facility of its kind in the nation.

Protesters made clear these sentiments are not driven by a not-in-my-backyard mentality — many of the Harlem protesters support the overall creation of overdose prevention services. But these residents have been galvanized by the fact that most of the patients attending opioid programs in Harlem do not live in Harlem. That first came to light in 2019 when a community group called the Greater Harlem Coalition requested data from the New York State Office of Addiction Services and Supports (OASAS), which is responsible for licensing clinics.

In an independent analysis of the updated data for 2019-2020, WNYC/Gothamist found that fewer than 25% of admissions — 605 people — to Harlem clinics were Harlem residents. The remaining 75% were patients — 1,841 people — who traveled from as far as Staten Island or Westchester to get to the clinics. Some patients travel upwards of two hours from areas with far fewer programs than Harlem, and long commutes are known to impede the delivery of addiction care. Mapping the city’s centers and their programs reveals a concentration in Harlem and the south Bronx.

These areas do rank among the highest in New York City when it comes to drug overdoses, particularly with opioids. But a recently released top-15 list for 2020 also includes far away neighborhoods such as Stapleton, St. George and Tottenville in Staten Island or East New York, Bed Stuy and Crown Heights in Brooklyn, and Rockaway, in Queens. The Bronx saw the biggest citywide jump in opioid death rate from 2019 to 2020, followed by Queens, Brooklyn, Staten Island and Manhattan. 
That’s why Sharpton, along with a host of community groups, are pushing back. They say Harlem is overburdened by programs that are much needed by vulnerable New Yorkers, but often placed in minority communities with the least power to resist them rather than being equitably distributed throughout the city. Some advocates are also pushing for better access and looser restrictions to at-home overdose remedies.
Click listen in player.