Critics Week: A List for Listmakers

Weekly Roundup | May 4, 2010

Debashish Bhattacharya

So remember on Tuesday when we were asking whether critics were irrelevant or irreplaceable? And I said that there were a few old-fashioned print critics, like Jon Pareles of the Times, that I still found important and useful? Well I’ve seen Jon’s list of the best World Music of 2008, and it turns out I don’t need him.

I’m kidding, of course, but just barely. Jon’s list features a number of my favorite world music artists (Debashish Bhattacharya, the great Indian slide guitarist; Toumani Diabate, the Malian kora virtuoso; and Franco, one of the founders of the global phenomenon we now call Afropop). When I see that, I think, “hey, I could’ve put this list together myself.” Except I couldn’t have, really… Jon’s list also includes Huong Thanh and Nguyen Le’s “Fragile Beauty,” a recording I have not heard – or even heard of. Since so much of his Best Of list includes things I like too, this suggests I better start practicing how to say Huong Thanh and Nguyen Le. Guess I know what I’ll be downloading after today’s show…

And Jon’s list conspicuously leaves out the three great Touareg guitar bands who released albums in 2008 – Tinariwen, Toumast, and Terakaft. One of them will definitely be on my top-10 list, as soon as I figure out how to tell them apart. (Actually, Tinariwen’s 2008 release is a gatefold 2-LP version of 2007’s “Aman Iman,” so I guess that leaves just two of these desert-fighters-turned-electric-guitarist bands eligible for this year’s lists.)

Tell us: What world music recordings caught your ear in 2008? Leave a comment.

Top Stories

Goodbye, WQXR's Jeff Spurgeon

Crown Heights residents fume over new barricades ahead of West Indian Day parade

Gloria Steinem in Conversation with David Remnick, from 2015

60 Words

YOU ARE ONLINE