Judge Says State Teachers' Union Can't Raise Extra Money for Perkins
A federal judge has ruled that the state teachers' union cannot spend more than the existing $6,000 limit to help re-elect Harlem State Sen. Bill Perkins.
New York State United Teachers had argued that the contribution limit on its political action committee violates its right to free speech. It wanted a temporary restraining order so its PAC could make independent expenditures, including polling, direct mail, canvassing, phone calling and a get-out-the-vote drive on Perkins' behalf. In court documents, the union also said it feared the state's strict limits could affect its ability to publish special newsletters supporting Perkins.
But the state successfully argued that its contribution limit is a valid means of leveling the playing field. It also rejected the union's suggestion that a limit on PAC spending violated free speech in the aftermath of the Supreme Court's ruling in the Citizens United case, which found corporate funding of independent political broadcasts can't be limited under the First Amendment. The State Office of the Attorney General, which represented the state's Board of Elections, claimed the Citizens United case had no bearing on contributions by political action committees.
Not surprisingly, the judge's decision was embraced by Perkins' challenger, Basil Smikle. He said he suspects the union is threatened by his candidacy because he supports charter schools, which often don't have unionized teachers.
"It seems this is really about supporting themselves and supporting Bill Perkins," he said. "Not really about supporting children."
Perkins became a lightning rod this year by opposing legislation to expand the number of charter schools, which have been rapidly growing in his Harlem district. Perkins wanted to prevent for-profit managment companies from running charters. But the legislature eventually passed a bill allowing more of the privately run public schools in order to boost the state's chances of winning federal Race to the Top education aid.
A spokesman for the state teachers' union declined to comment on the case. The suit was not joined by the United Federation of Teachers, which represents New York City teachers. The UFT has also endorsed Perkins.
Smikle is a political consultant who worked for Hillary Clinton. He's raised $159,000 since announcing his candidacy in May. Perkins has raised $78,000 since then, though he's raised a total of nearly $259,000. Many of his contributions come from unions and political action committees, which is typical of incumbents. He's been in office since 2006 and was previously a City Council member from Harlem.



