'This Is My Second Chance': Manhattan Expands Alternative Justice Program

Starting in July, adults who are arrested in Manhattan on low-level, non-violent offenses may have a chance to walk away from the criminal justice system with nothing on their record. The price of getting off without serving time is even more gentle than a slap on the wrist. Eligible participants will go through a few hours of group therapy or arts programming.

The diversion program, known as Project Reset, is part of an expanded initiative from the Manhattan District Attorney's Office, along with several non-profits. Since 2015, the program has been available to 16 and 17-year-olds who are arrested for the first time in Manhattan, as well as a few precincts in the Bronx and Brooklyn. 90% of teens who are diverted to the program complete it, according to The Center for Court Innovation. Recidivism among that group is less than 10%.  

"So much of the time, as prosecutors and law enforcement officials, we're taking something out of the community," said Manhattan D.A. Cy Vance, referring to people prosecuted for more serious offenses. "It's just as important in our business to put something into the community."

About 215 adults have gone through Project Reset since February, when some Manhattan precincts began using the program. It's set to go into effect in the rest of the borough on July 1.

Several alumni describe the program as a fresh start after a brush with the law.

"This is my second chance, it’s helped me better myself," said Jose Machicote, 16. "Now I actually have a job at a restaurant, and if wouldn’t have came to this program, I would have had a record where I wouldn’t have been able to get a job," he said. 

But many program providers argue the eligibility is too narrow, and should be expanded beyond individuals arrested for low-level, non-violent crimes.

Eventually, those arrested for certain weapons charges, loitering, and prostitution charges should also be able to participate, said a spokesman for The Center for Court Innovation. The Manhattan DA has set aside $8 million for Project Reset over the next three years. Vance's office says it is considering expanding the program for other offenses, but did not give any specifics.