What voters really wanted this election cycle

On Point | Nov 4

The midterm elections have been focused on who will control Congress, but voters have also been weighing in on who will control their state in 36 gubernatorial races and over 140 ballot initiatives. A breakdown on the down ballot races and issues.

Guests

Jessica Taylor, Senate and Governors editor for The Cook Political Report with Amy Walter.

Darrell West, Senior fellow in the Center for Technology Innovation at the Brookings Institution.

Reid Wilson, Founder and editor of Pluribus News, a digital media outlet focused on state politics and policy.

____

Transcript of Full Broadcast

The version of our broadcast available at the top of this page and via podcast apps is a condensed version of the full show. You can listen to the full, unedited broadcast here:

Part I

MEGHNA CHAKRABARTI: Today it’s our first of two days talking about last night’s historic election. We’re looking at the state level today and the wins that Democrats had in governor’s offices and state legislatures, and a little bit later in the show we’ll look at the all-important ballot questions that voters were asked to look at, because I think when it comes to actual policy, that’s the most direct place to see what voters actually want.

And Jessica Taylor joins us today. She’s Senate and governor’s editor for the Cook Political Report with Amy Walter. And Jessica, let’s talk about Ohio, because there, Democrat Amy Acton defeated Republican challenger Vivek Ramaswamy in one of the most expensive governor’s races in the country.

Ramaswamy not only had President Trump’s endorsement, but he’s a major face in the MAGA movement. He also ran an historically unpopular or reviled, I should say, ad in the last days of the election. Acton served as Ohio’s chief public health officer during COVID. She’s the first woman ever to serve as governor in Ohio, and here she is last night.

AMY ACTON: This entire campaign has been a movement by and for the people. This win is for every Ohioan who has longed for public servants again. Who solve problems instead of making them. And who do not mistake kindness for weakness. Because of your hard work Ohio has chosen unity and decency over division and hate. The healing begins today.

CHAKRABARTI: Jessica, campaigns are long and hard, so I don’t want to take anything away from Amy Acton’s campaign. But for those people who may have been undecided, especially independents in Iowa maybe in this past last couple of weeks, that ad from Ramaswamy, do you think it actually pushed people in one direction or another?

TAYLOR: I think that this race was already trending in Acton’s favor, and I think we saw that with the Senate race, of course, also going Democratic. But I do think that it pushed some people, particularly women. I think that if you saw, if you knew Acton’s backstory about how she was raped by her stepfather, which is something that she has talked about on the campaign trail, and the poverty that she grew up in, and her relationship with her estranged mother, I think it was just a political ad that was just so below the belt.

And Ramaswamy was already having likability issues, and I think favorability issues. It was notable to me that he really didn’t appear in any of his own ads. He had other people or his family appearing in them. So he came across very polarizing when he ran for president in 2024, and I think that extended to this race for governor as well.

CHAKRABARTI: Also in Ohio, Sherrod Brown won for the Senate race there, and so once again, we have a strong pairing in terms on the Democratic side of the ticket, just like we saw in Texas, Georgia as well. So that’s a pattern there. But I have to ask you, Jessica, this is a question that’s been floating around, since about midnight last night.

This election, this midterm, happened with a historically unpopular president. President Trump’s approval ratings are way down in the bottom of the Grand Canyon, people deeply unhappy with his impact on the economy. And then as you said, Ramaswamy is a good example of this.

There’s a major likability kind of a issue, a lack of decency issue. So did the Democrats that we’re talking about win these elections, or did Republicans lose them?

TAYLOR: I think Republicans lost them, and it will be up to Democrats what lessons they take away. They should not rest on their laurels and feel like this was a complete vindication of everything that their party stands for.

Republicans were in power across the country. They had the most governor’s races across the country. They had the Senate majority. They had the House majority. They had state legislative majorities. The backlash that we are seeing, I think, is toward the incumbent party, and Democrats, we’re going to see they’re without a leader of their party right now.

Who do they turn to in 2028? Who do Republicans turn to in a post-Trump era? And how did they, how does the MAGA movement move forward for that regard? But again, Democrats should not make the same mistake, they misread the 2022 midterms in particular because they were not as bad for the White House and you saw Biden run for a second term, and we all saw what happened with that.

So they really have to, I think, work to earn the trust of the American people because what we see in polling is that both parties are unpopular. It’s just that Democrats were the party out of power, and so they were slightly less unpopular than Republicans, and certainly less unpopular than Trump.

CHAKRABARTI: Yeah, to be brutally honest, I would say if the Democrats hadn’t won so decisively in so many races, it would prove, even if they had won, but only by thin margins, if you can’t win by a massive margin in multiple races against a party that has basically hollowed itself out and sold to one man, it’s not a sort of a groundswell of national support for what Democrats stand for, whatever that may be.

TAYLOR: Yeah, I think Democrats … they need to articulate what they stand for, and I think that’s going to be in the policies that they have at the state houses from the governor’s level, and then in the Senate and in the House.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so let’s listen to what happened in Iowa.

Iowa’s Rob Sand was elected to be the first Democratic governor there since 2006, so in 20 years. Now, President Trump carried Iowa by more than 13 points just two years ago. Sand was a two-term state auditor, and he ran on issues of government accountability and cross-party cooperation. He talked about that when he addressed his supporters in his victory speech last night.

SAND: So many of you feel what I feel about the divisiveness of our political system, and you were excited to have somebody as a candidate in your party who was actually talking about that and focusing on it. But even among those of you that don’t like that part as much, the vast majority of you understood that the smallest party has to appeal to reasonable-minded people in other parties if it wants to build a coalition that reaches a majority. Because of all of us coming together in January, no Iowan has to fear their government anymore.

CHAKRABARTI: Here’s another one. This is in Nevada, where Attorney General Aaron Ford beat the state’s Republican governor, Joe Lombardo. This was considered a very competitive race and a significant victory for Democrats because Aaron Ford will be Nevada’s first ever Black governor.

Here he is last night.

AARON FORD: This campaign didn’t happen by accident. It happened because of faith, because of family, because of hard work and because the people of Nevada decided that our best days are still ahead of us.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, Jessica, I know I gotta let you go in just a minute here, so my last question for you is, I’d say the received wisdom for quite a while was that national-level Democrats had kinda given up at the state level in a lot of different places in the United States.

And that left state party officials to fend for themselves, to fight on their own, and I’m wondering now if the national-level Democrats should be paying much more attention to what their counterparts are doing on the ground in these states that they had at the national level written off.

TAYLOR: We really saw Democrats decimated at the state level during the Obama era, and there was not a lot of party-building that went on. Democrats now have a majority of governors’ races for the first time since 2010. They’re winning back state legislative races. A lot are still uncalled. We’ll see how wide the breadth of that victory is, but they’ve got to invest at the state level.

We saw that does take money, and that’s what Democrats didn’t have a lot of. The Democratic National Committee was basically broke this cycle, and they can’t assume that being outspent by Republicans, that they will come out on victory every other time, so I think they have to invest at the state level, so that’s something that I’m watching to see if they can do.

CHAKRABARTI: Yeah, and it seems like the national Democrats should also be looking to the state level for the next generation of Democratic leaders as well, but Jessica Taylor, I know you have a busy day ahead of you. I hope that at the end of the day you get many hours of deeply restful sleep. She’s Senate and governors editor for the Cook Political Report with Amy Walter.

Thanks so much, Jessica.

TAYLOR: You’re welcome. Thanks.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so that was a very quick survey of some consequential governors’ races around the country. Let’s move to ballot questions because there were over 140, maybe even 150 ballot questions in dozens of states across the country. More than 40 of them had to deal with data centers, and most data center restrictions voters actually passed those restrictions by 75 to 80% of voters saying no to data centers.

So in Ohio, at least 14 municipalities passed bans. Republican Ohio voter Hunter Willmitch was in an interview with the BBC, and he summed up how voters feel about those data centers.

I think if a local community chooses to want a data center in their community, they have the right to have that in their local community. If a local community chooses, “Let’s not have this data center,” because they look at the cons of the data center and things like that, I think they have the right to say no to the data center.

Darrell West joins us now. He’s senior fellow in the Center for Technology Innovation at the Brookings Institution, and he’s been taking a look at public sentiment about data centers.

Darrell, welcome to the show.

DARRELL WEST: Meghna, nice to be with you.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so your thoughts about not just how voters said no in many states to data centers, but by the wide margin.

WEST: Yeah, that was the big surprise for me last night. It was a very rough night for data centers in general. There were a number of ballot measures across the country.

Almost all of them ended up passing, but it was really the size of that margin that surprised me. So I’m a native of Ohio. There were a bunch of ballot measures in Ohio, so I looked at some of those areas. Upper Sandusky, which is an area just north of Columbus, 77% of the voters there basically expressed opposition to data centers.

In the southwestern part of the state, Urbana is a place 77% voted against data centers. Trenton, also in the southwestern part of the state, 80% voted no. So it wasn’t just the negative vote against data centers, but just the complete almost unity of the public opinion against it, and it really shows that the opposition to data centers has become truly a bipartisan issue.

CHAKRABARTI: Indeed. So let me ask you, let’s take a step back here because this was one of those issues that maybe a year ago no one would have thought that it could be decisive in the election. Do you think that data centers appearing as a question on ballots in multiple states actually maybe brought people to the polls who otherwise could have been disinterested in the candidates they could potentially vote for?

WEST: You’re right. If you go back a year ago, data centers were not nearly as controversial as they have become. People today worry about the energy, water, and land use aspects. There have been a number of public opinion surveys showing more than 70% of Americans across the country have serious reservations about data centers.

So it was a surprise not just that the sentiment turned negative as quickly as it did, but in the exit polls last night there actually were questions indicating that data centers were a major factor in how people voted. It related to, for example, the Democratic critique on affordability.

In a lot of states, people have seen their electric rates going up, and obviously there are lots of things that have increased electric rates, the Iran war oil prices, and so on. But people blame data centers and the very extensive energy needs that they have for raising their personal costs. So data centers became an issue not just in terms of the data center, but in terms of the affordability problems that people perceived they were creating for ordinary individuals.

CHAKRABARTI: I wonder if data centers also serve as a very physical and large and in-your-face representation of the lack of control that many Americans are feeling in their lives, right? The existence of AI being one thing, but we covered data centers in different states, including Utah, and a lot of people there were telling us what we don’t like is that even though we’ve said we don’t want it, the data center shows up.

They start breaking ground no matter what. We find that there were deals made in back rooms in the state house. And so was it an ever-present symbol of the disconnect between people and their representatives and also just the way technology is changing lives?

WEST: People do feel a loss of human agency over technology. The tech companies are big and powerful. A number of them are now trillion-dollar companies, and people just look at technology. They have worries about AI. We’ve seen the headlines about AI taking jobs, AI agents going rogue and ending up in places where they don’t belong, and people feel like they don’t really have control over AI because the tech companies can basically roll out whatever digital products they want.

But the data center issue became a focus of some of the anti-tech sentiment. Because to build a data center, since it is a physical infrastructure, it requires local construction permits. And as soon as people started to feel the various worries they had about AI, they discovered data centers provided a venue for them to express their opposition, and on that particular issue, they did have human agency.

And in a number of states, organizations popped up. They were grassroots organizations and very much citizen-led, basically saying, “Hey, we have doubts about these.” A lot of these projects were negotiated under non-disclosure agreements with the local officials, so people didn’t even know what the deal was.

And so people basically realized if they could convince their city council, their zoning board, or the local planning commission to vote no, and that might just be convincing three out of five members of those various bodies to vote no, they could stop the data center, and that has happened in a number of communities, and many places have adopt moratoriums or at least pauses on data center construction.

And so the data center became the vehicle by which people gained some control over technology and also expressed some of their doubts about AI in general.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so Darrell, let me also ask you, I mentioned that there were at least 40 ballot measures, but they were not in 40 states.

It was in roughly, what, 12, 13 states, meaning a lot of these questions were hyperlocal, right? They weren’t even maybe questions that people statewide were voting on. Is that correct?

WEST: That is correct. Almost all of these ballot measures were specific to individual communities. But you’re right, it was spread out in more than a dozen different states.

Ohio had by far the largest number, so we’ve talked a little bit about that. But other communities in states where there were large votes against data centers was in Florida. In one community, 77% voted to prohibit data centers. In Illinois, there were half a dozen communities that had ballot measures.

I looked up the votes, and anywhere from 74% to 88% of the people in those communities voted against data centers. Janesville, Wisconsin, I thought was an interesting area. You may recall that is Paul Ryan’s hometown, the conservative Republican who used to be Speaker of the House.

That community voted 62% against data centers. So it was just interesting, the wide variety of states. Some were liberal places, some were conservative places, but the public votes against data centers was big in almost every one of those communities.

CHAKRABARTI: Darrell, we have just about 30 seconds left before our next break here.

So this is a midterm. The next major election is coming along in two years. Do you think, what lessons do you think the people running in 2028 should take from this not just data center, but as you just said, anti-tech sentiment?

WEST: The lesson I take is we need human guardrails in place against AI and other technologies.

The United States has been very libertarian for the last 25 years. We haven’t had a lot of government rules in this area. If you look at every other area, finance, education, health care, there are government rules that govern those entities. I think the lesson that many politicians are going to get out of this is we actually need to start legislating in this area.

We start to need to engage in oversight and start to regulate these entities.

Part III

CHAKRABARTI: Reid Wilson joins us now. He’s founder and editor of Pluribus News, a digital media outlet that’s focused on state politics and policy. Reid, welcome to On Point.

REID WILSON: Hi, Meghna. How are you?

CHAKRABARTI: I’m doing great. Just the other day I was surprised when our producer, Paige, said that there’s only 26 states that provide for statewide initiative processes.

Now, I guess I’ve lived in two of them, and so I thought it happened everywhere, but I guess grassroots-initiated ballot questions are not in all 50 states.

WILSON: Yes, they are not in all 50 states, that’s correct. There are different flavors of initiatives. So a legislature might refer a question to the ballot.

Most states allow that. Only 26 states allow a ballot measure to be referred by citizens who go out and collect signatures and try to get something on the ballot. And then there are other states where there are veto referenda, where a citizen group can petition to repeal a measure that the state legislature has passed.

In the states that do allow initiatives, basically what we see is in conservative states, progressives use the ballot measure to pass popular progressive policy that would never make it through a Republican legislature. And in progressive states, conservative activists trying to pass popular conservative policy that would never make it through a Democratic legislature.

That’s the way things have been used in the last couple of years.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so we’ve had 140 ballot questions this year. I presume that’s a combination of those initiated ballot questions plus the legislatively referred ones?

WILSON: There are some that have been where citizens go collect signatures, get something on the ballot, and others where legislatures have put things on the ballot to ask voters for.

Sometimes legislatures do that because they don’t want to be the ones responsible for, say, raising taxes. In other cases, you might see conservative legislatures putting a contentious culture war issue on the ballot in hopes of getting more voters out to the polls.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, taxes. Let’s talk about that, because that was an important question in many states.

At the very beginning of the show, I mentioned how out in North Carolina, while many Democrats won in surprise races in North Carolina, that doesn’t mean those very same voters who put them in office yesterday were in favor of much more progressive taxation policy, because North Carolina voters basically voted to put tax caps in place in North Carolina, both on income tax and local property taxes, which is interesting.

So now let’s go out to, let’s go out to California, because we see something similar there. Obviously, the Democratic stronghold in the United States, but in California, voters there had a question in front of them about a 5% one-time tax on individuals and trusts with over a billion dollars in assets.

That did not pass in the state of California. Here’s Democratic Governor Gavin Newsom. He was against the ballot question.

GAVIN NEWSOM: He’s right about addressing this issue. On this issue, we fundamentally disagree. This particular initiative, I disagree with him, and so do many members of labor unions and organizations that admire Bernie Sanders.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so Governor Newsom there talking about Bernie Sanders supporting that 5% one-time tax. More locally, here’s California Congressman Ro Khanna, who really went after Governor Newsom for opposing the measure.

RO KHANNA: You would tax 250 billionaires who have half the California economy their worth, $2.1 trillion, and you would tax them 5%, even though their wealth has gone up 144% over the last three years.

And to do that, you would be able to make sure the 3.5 million Californians didn’t lose their healthcare and poor kids didn’t go without health care. It is the most obvious decision for someone to make who cares about the working class and children. So why is Governor Newsom opposed to this tax? He’s opposed to this tax because of the billionaires bankrolling his campaigns.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, Reid, let me take back what I said earlier, because California being on the West Coast, I should say it’s actually still, at this point in time, 10:45 a.m. Eastern, probably a little still too early to call whether or not that Proposition 40 is going to pass. But your take on the fact that it’s even close, that it may not?

WILSON: One of the things I love about ballot measures is it shows the nuance that voters can hold in their head in a way that partisan politics doesn’t. I don’t think that any voter in America is 100% in agreement with the Democratic platform or 100% in agreement with the Republican platform, and this vote shows that.

So one of the interesting things about California is that it relies substantially on the capital gains tax for its income, the way it gets revenue from the wealthy. If a bunch of billionaires flee the state before this tax would take effect, that’ll have much longer-term ramifications for California’s budget.

So you can, a voter can think to themselves, “Yes, I want to tax the rich more, but maybe not in a way that makes them flee the state.” At the same time, voters were asked whether or not to require local governments to get two-thirds of the vote for new taxes. They defeated that measure by a 50, a 45 to 55% margin, or I should say, just as you made the caveat, they’re still counting ballots out there, but it’s trailing by a 45/55 margin.

So interestingly there, voters are leaving the option for local governments to raise their own taxes open, while at the same time not taxing the assets of billionaires. And you can sort of see how those two votes make sense at the same time because of the possible future fiscal ramifications that something like that might happen.

CHAKRABARTI: Yeah. Yeah. Point well taken. And California’s so interesting to me too, because on the one hand we’re talking about, as you heard Ro Khanna say, like 250 people in the state who would fall under that 1%, one-time tax. But the threat of those specific people leaving was, I think, enough for folks to really pause on whether or not to support this.

But at the same time, as we’ve been hearing throughout the hour, this major concern about the power of billionaires in this country, right? And the money that they’re pouring into elections, how the radical inequality income in this country is feeling like it’s being cemented in place.

That and in California, affordability has got to be the number one issue on the minds of many people, especially young voters. But at the same time, it seems like this one-time tax, at this point, doesn’t have enough votes to pass.

WILSON: Yep. And I think you can draw a line between taxing the rich more and making California more affordable for everybody, but I think voters are smart enough to make distinctions about how you levy that tax.

Sure, raise taxes on the wealthy’s income rather than assets. I just, I love the ballot initiative because it allows voters to express the nuances of complicated policy thought.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so here’s one nuance that I see emerging, and that is voters have clearly said, for a variety of reasons, they don’t like what Republicans are doing right now, whether it’s just, it’s President Trump and the Iran war or the handling of the economy, and they’re looking to Democrats for something better.

But on the other hand, through these ballot initiatives, it does seem as if maybe they wouldn’t, voters may not be on board for sort of radical taxation changes, in terms of how to pay for whatever Democrats might want to do nationally going down the line. Would you draw that connection there, or am I going a step too far?

WILSON: No, and I’ll point to my home state of Washington, where we have never had an income tax. And earlier this year, the state, the Democratic-controlled state legislature levied a tax on incomes over a million dollars. The first time in the state’s history that we’ve ever taxed income.

Opponents of that put a measure on the ballot to repeal the millionaires tax. That tax survived. The repeal effort failed by a 42% to 58% margin. So I think voters are open to thinking about new ways of levying a tax and some of those efforts are going to succeed and some are going to fail.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay. Yeah, I’m looking at the latest right now from Washington. It looks like at this point in time still not all the votes counted, but you’re right, looks like 60/40 against repealing that. Okay, let’s move to a bunch of initiatives or ballot questions that were in four different states that have to do with abortion.

Questions appeared in the states of Missouri, Nevada, Virginia, and Idaho, and in three of those states, voters, in various ways chose to preserve or enshrine abortion rights. In one of them, it’s Idaho, voters chose to keep a ban in place, and here’s how local station KTVB reported on that just this morning.

This was a highly debated ballot measure that would restore reproductive freedom and privacy rights. The rejection means there’s no change to Idaho’s current abortion laws, meaning abortion is illegal in Idaho except when necessary to prevent the death of the pregnant woman or in reported cases of rape or incest.

CHAKRABARTI: Reid, your thoughts on Idaho and especially vis-a-vis Missouri, which I want to talk about in a minute, but Nevada and Virginia that chose to, voters there chose to protect abortion rights.

WILSON: So this ballot over abortion rights started after the Supreme Court’s decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Clinic that overturned Roe v. Wade, and a number of states with the ballot initiative immediately went out and tried to enshrine abortion rights in their state constitutions or in their state law.

Nevada and Virginia have these weird like two-step processes where two separate legislatures have to prove a proposed constitutional amendment before it goes to voters, so they’re just basically two years late to the party. In Missouri, two years ago, voters passed a measure to protect abortion rights to put that in the Constitution.

This was an effort placed on the ballot by the Republican legislature to overturn that measure and once again ban abortion rights. That measure failed, and so abortion rights remain in the state constitution by a 45 to 55% margin. Idaho is the first real state that has, I shouldn’t say real state.

Idaho is the first state that has rejected a straight-up abortion rights measure in the wake of Dobbs. Some very conservative states have approved a protection for abortion rights. Idaho voters, not going to do it, and so they rejected an abortion rights measure. The last results that I saw had it at 44% to 56%.

CHAKRABARTI: Let’s be honest. This is exactly what the Supreme Court said it wanted in the Dobbs decision, right? Which was voters in various states to make decisions for themselves.

WILSON: Yeah, and that gets a little complicated in the other 24 states where voters don’t have that authority to take a ballot initiative to the polls.

CHAKRABARTI: Ah, interesting point. Okay. Let’s go back to Virginia here for a moment, because all three of the questions before voters there passed, I believe. We talked about the abortion one. There was another one on marriage equality, that passed, and then an interesting one of returning voting rights to people convicted of felonies after they have completed their sentences.

Do you see any pattern in other states when it comes to voting rights in the United States?

WILSON: Oh, yeah. Absolutely. So there have been a ton of measures this year that focus on the initiative process itself. I talked a little bit about how conservative activists use the initiative in progressive states, and vice versa.

One thing that legislatures really don’t like is when voters take away some of their power, and by passing a ballot initiative. So one of the things we saw this year was a whole bunch of states proposing measures that would raise the threshold that it takes to actually qualify for the ballot.

So that might mean you have to gather more signatures, or you have to gather signatures in specific areas, or you have to a ballot measure must pass with 60% of the vote instead of 50% of the vote. It’s been an effort, a nationwide effort to curtail the rights of the ballot initiative over time.

Now, most of those measures lost last night. And voters I think the through line in a lot of this, whether it’s abortion rights passing in most states, or gun rights bills passing in a lot of states around the country in Alaska, a repeal of ranked choice voting failed, or a measure to limit the initiative process most of those going down as well.

I think the throughline is voters do not like it when politicians try to take away their rights. And those could be gun rights, those could be abortion rights, those could be initiative rights. They don’t want their rights taken away.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so one more little set of interesting things. Again, I just love that Brandeis quote, because I absolutely think it’s true in terms of states being laboratories of democracy.

In Michigan and Montana, there were some proposals that had to do with money and politics, right? And Prop 2 in Michigan would ban electric and gas utilities and government contractors from making campaign donations, and in Montana, Initiative 194, I think it’s the first sort of really concerted pushback against Citizens United, because that measure would have corporations, nonprofits, and labor unions, or quote-unquote, “artificial persons” being banned from doing business in the state if they contribute to political campaigns.

Both of those passed.

WILSON: Yes, they did, and I think voters do like the idea of getting money out of politics. In Michigan, the utilities bill is something that I think you might see expand to other states as well because in most state legislatures, the biggest lobbying entity is the local utility.

It’s Old Dominion in Virginia or Duke Energy in North Carolina or PG&E in California. Utilities have a lot of money. They have a lot of business before the state, and so they end up spending a lot of that money lobbying and on political campaigns. If you want to go after money and politics, the utility is a pretty good place to start.

CHAKRABARTI: Okay. Tell me a little bit more about Montana because I love Montana. I grew up in Oregon, next door to you in Washington, so the Mountain West will always be near and dear to my heart. But it’s not exactly a state that I would have pointed to and say, “This is the place where pushback against Citizens United might get the ball rolling.”

WILSON: I’m not sure about that. Okay. I think there are a sort of, I don’t know. It’s a weird coalition between Montana in that voters there are, they have shown that they are very pro-environment. Yes. They are very pro hunting and fishing and being outdoors.

They are a state where they, just yesterday, they added the right to an initiative, to a ballot measure, to the state’s declaration of rights, which is a part of their state constitution. So there’s a sort of anti, I don’t want to say anti-government, but anti-government control maybe as a part of this.

Let’s also back up here. 100 years ago, the ballot initiative became a big deal in a lot of Western states, including Montana, Oregon, Idaho, Washington, our little corner of the country, as a way for citizens to take back power from the robber barons and timber barons who controlled the state legislatures. So there is a history here of voters, especially in those Western states, wanting to reserve the right to change state policy for themselves.

This article was originally published on WBUR.org.

Top Stories

Hakeem Jeffries gets party nod as House Speaker, but NYC's left remains wary

Is it Safe to Fly?

Advice for Deciding Whether to Have a Kid

Samantha Sloyan On Playing the Mother of 'Carrie'; DOCNYC: What Happens When You Decide to Break a Non-Disclosure Agreement?

YOU ARE ONLINE