America has expanded veteran benefits. Is it reaching veterans?
Congress has said it wants to take better care of military veterans, but the country has a $7.3 trillion debt for it as of last year. How to pay for the care veterans, and their families, deserve.
Guests
Linda Bilmes, the Daniel Patrick Moynihan Senior Lecturer in Public Policy and Public Finance at the Harvard Kennedy School. Author of “The Three Trillion Dollar War: The True Cost of the Iraq Conflict” and the forthcoming “The Ghost Budget: Paying for America’s Wars.”
Paul Sullivan, veteran and veteran advocate. He served as an Army cavalry scout during the 1991 Gulf war. Former project manager at the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs.
Also Featured
Kayla Williams, Army veteran.
John Medve, retired Army officer and former employee at the Department of Veterans Affairs.
____
The version of our broadcast available at the top of this page and via podcast apps is a condensed version of the full show. You can listen to the full, unedited broadcast here:
Part I
MEGHNA CHAKRABARTI: On March 4, 1865, President Abraham Lincoln gave his second inaugural address. The Civil War was coming to a close, and it had left the nation and those who had fought for its union traumatized. Lincoln closed his address with its most famous line of, quote, “With malice toward none, with charity for all. Let us strive on to finish the work we are in,” end quote.
Lesser known are the words Lincoln uttered right after that. He said, quote, “To care for him who shall have borne the battle and for his widow and his orphan.” That phrase became the motto of the Department of Veterans Affairs. It hangs on the wall at VA headquarters in Washington.
As the VA says on its own website, quote, “This singular act codified a social contract between the nation and our veterans, that the VA would always be there to help veterans and their families heal and recover from the illnesses, injuries, or wounds sustained in service to America.” Since then, the nation has repeatedly expanded the definition of healing and recovery.
There’s, of course, the World War II-era GI Bill, and much later in 2008, George W. Bush massively restored educational benefits for veterans, often referred to as the post 9/11 GI Bill.
BUSH: This is a responsibility all of us in Washington share, not as Republicans or Democrats, but as Americans, and I want to thank the leaders of the House and Senate.
CHAKRABARTI: On July 10, 2010, President Barack Obama announced another set of benefits expansions to better aid veterans dealing with one of the most common wounds of war.
OBAMA: Just as we have a solemn responsibility to train and equip our troops before we send them into harm’s way, we have a solemn responsibility to provide our veterans and wounded warriors with the care and benefits they’ve earned when they come home. That’s our sacred trust with all who serve, and it doesn’t end when their tour of duty does.
CHAKRABARTI: The VA had made a, quote, “historic rule change that would make it easier for veterans suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder to get care and disability compensation.”
OBAMA: This is a long overdue step that will help veterans, not just of the Afghan and Iraq wars, but generations of their brave predecessors who proudly served and sacrificed in all our wars. It’s a step that proves that America will always be there for our veterans, just as they’ve always been there for us.
CHAKRABARTI: Before the rule change, veterans had to produce documented evidence that they’d been in firefights or bombings that could have caused PTSD. That documentation was very time-consuming and often impossible to find. After the rule change, veterans needed only to show that they served in a war and performed duties where traumatic events could have occurred.
In 2010, a congressional analysis put the cost of these expanded benefits at $5 billion. 12 years later, veteran benefits were massively expanded again.
BIDEN: The PACT Act is the least we can do for the countless men and women, many of whom may be in this room for all I know, who suffered toxicity exposure while serving their country.
CHAKRABARTI: That’s President Joe Biden on August 10th, 2022.
BIDEN: The law expands access to healthcare and disability benefits for veterans harmed by toxic exposure. It empowers the Department of Veterans Affairs to move quickly to determine service members’ illness and related military service to see if they qualify. And for families of veterans who died from toxicity exposure, it means a monthly stipend of $2,000 a month for a surviving spouse with two children. It means access to life insurance, home loan insurance, tuition benefits, and help with health care.
CHAKRABARTI: The PACT Act is one of the largest health care and benefits expansions in VA history.
As of April of 2026, the VA says it’s approved more than 2.4 million PACT Act related claims. Linda Bilmes is a leading expert on defense budgets, the public financing of war, and the cost of war to the veterans who fought them. She’s at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government and joins us now.
Linda, welcome back to On Point.
LINDA BILMES: Thank you. I’m thinking of Lincoln’s quote about striving on to finish the work that we’re in, Linda, and that, of course, regarding veteran care. It doesn’t just require changing the law, right? It also requires being sure resources are in place to do so. Do you think the nation has kept that part of its promise to veterans? Has the government set aside enough funds to cover these expanded benefits?
BILMES: We have made a lot of promises to veterans, and there is a very strong bipartisan desire to do so. But the wars have long-term costs. They always have long-term costs, and every war we have ever fought has had a long tail of costs, and paying veterans benefits is something that peaks 50, 60 years later.
Now, in this case, we have expanded promised benefits, but we have not set aside any money to pay for these benefits. So U.S. has now accumulated $7.3 trillion, that’s trillion with a T, in projected veterans disability compensation.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay, I’m going to stop you right there.
BILMES: Yes.
CHAKRABARTI: So we have expanded these benefits.
BILMES: Yes.
CHAKRABARTI: But we have not set aside any money to pay for benefits that we have already approved, disability benefits, things like that?
BILMES: That’s right. So these are disability benefits, not including health care, just disability compensation for living veterans that has already been approved, already been awarded, and that veterans are depending on.
But we have not set aside one penny to pay those accrued benefits.
CHAKRABARTI: And the balance sheet for that, you said, is already $7.3 trillion.
BILMES: $7.3 trillion. I talk to my students about the fact that a trillion seconds ago is when wooly mammoths were walking around. This is a very large number. And it’s hard to fathom how quickly this has grown.
It’s grown 70% in the last three years for a whole variety of reasons. But the promises are great. It’s nice to promise, but I have argued and testified and written that we should be setting aside money to take care of those who fight the wars at the same time that we send them.
CHAKRABARTI: So Linda, forgive me for having my jaw hanging down here because just from a sheer common sense point of view I don’t quite understand how this happened, like how these very deserved benefits expansion, I want to underscore what you just said, that no one’s saying that veterans should not get these benefits, like almost all of America agrees. But that when the expansions occurred, there was no companion effort to be sure money was set aside so that we could cover them for the many, many decades that the benefits would go out to deserving veterans.
I just don’t understand how that happened.
BILMES: Well, I would say that to some extent the scale of what we owe snuck up on us. There are many reasons why veterans claim more than they used to. First of all, many good reasons, higher survival rates, better medical care, much better survival rates from injuries, more recognition of a wider range of medical conditions, as well as military service factors, like more repeated deployments and longer tours and shorter periods of time between deployments, the greater use of contractors, much greater outreach by the VA, to some extent, simplified process, to some extent less stigma for applying for mental health conditions expanded eligibility, and then the PACT Act, which changed the structure of being able to apply for being exposed to toxins like Agent Orange and burn pit exposure. So all of these things have created an environment in which, for example, of the Iraq and Afghanistan veterans, about half of those several million individuals qualify for some disability benefits.
CHAKRABARTI: Because they were exposed. I understand.
BILMES: They were exposed or injured or had the compounding conditions.
CHAKRABARTI: Again, but we should’ve, Congress should’ve known this. The administrations that passed these should have known this. These aren’t hidden numbers. And I just want to also say that you said Agent Orange, so we’re talking also all the way back to exposures for the PACT Act that were suffered for in the Vietnam War, so decades ago.
But hang on for a second. You can see I’m going to struggle with this a little bit this hour, Linda, because when the Obama administration expanded the eligibility for coverage for PTSD, which, again, was long overdue. I quoted a number that a congressional study had back then saying these expanded benefits will cost $5 billion, which seems like such a laughably tiny number right now.
I can’t even, I just, as the kids say, I just can’t. But you’ve actually testified before Congress, and you did this, what, years ago, saying, “Guys, this is, the liability’s going to be in the trillions with a T.” You sounded the warning on this. What was the response from members of Congress?
BILMES: The response from the administration and members of Congress was that the numbers that I and my co-author, Joseph Stiglitz, were testifying were impossible.
But in fact, the actual numbers are so much higher than even what we had testified about back in 2010, that the whole point is moot. Because now we are dealing with what is the third-largest liability. There’s Social Security and Medicare and this liability, I consider it a form of deferred compensation to veterans.
Except that unlike Social Security and Medicare, there is no entity that is really looking at this and doing the actuarial math and figuring out a mechanism for paying for it.
CHAKRABARTI: Over many decades, right?
BILMES: Over many decades. And I just want to reinforce the point that this is not a new phenomenon.
In World War I, the peak year for paying for veterans’ benefits was in 1969, more than 50 years after armistice. For World War II, and my father was a World War II veteran, it was the peak year were in the 1980s. So what has changed is that we have more generous benefits, much better survival rates and also a very tiny percentage of the population that is serving.
Back in the days in World War II, you had 9 to 12 percentage of the population serving. Now you have half of 1%.
Part II
CHAKRABARTI: You’ll have to forgive me because I find so much of this just so hard to believe. I’m gonna ask you to repeat a couple of things. So you and your co-author for one of your books, Joseph Stiglitz, who happened to win the Nobel Prize in economics, and you’ve dedicated your career to studying defense budgets. Back in 2010 when the Obama administration, as I mentioned, had expanded benefits for coverage, easier coverage of PTSD at that time, you said you’d gone to the administration and to Congress and you had warned them not the $7 trillion number, but that it was going to be potentially in the trillions, yes?
BILMES: Yes.
CHAKRABARTI: And they said your numbers were wrong. They told you and a Nobel Prize winning economist your numbers were wrong.
BILMES: Yes.
CHAKRABARTI: Did they have any evidence to counter your numbers? On what basis were they saying that?
BILMES: Well, I think that there were a number of factors, but I think that people doing, there are a couple of issues.
One is that the Congressional Budget Office tends to forecast expenditures out 10 years. And we are looking out at the lifetime of veterans. So for example, right now the average age of some 80,000 service members who have been involved in Iran is 24. Now, assuming that they claim at the same rate as Iraq and Afghanistan veterans, so 50% of them will become eligible for some disability benefits as a result of their exposure to all of the toxins that have been intense over the past nine months.
We will be providing disability compensation to them for the next, for the rest of their lives, and they’re 24 now, so for the next 60 years. And I think that we have become much better at providing medical care and letting people know what they are eligible for, and providing outreach to veterans and recognizing their injuries across the board, but there are major fiscal consequences for this, which we have not reckoned with.
CHAKRABARTI: Yeah. It’s interesting, I just looked this up again because I couldn’t remember what Dr. Stiglitz had won the Nobel Prize for, and I just saw this again, that it’s for what happens with markets that have asymmetric information.
BILMES: That’s right.
CHAKRABARTI: Small gaps in information can produce market failures. This seems to be analogous to that. But one more quick thing before we’re gonna hear from a veteran in a second. You had said in the previous segment, Linda, that right now the three largest liabilities for the federal government are Social Security and Medicare, which have funding, imperfect funding mechanisms.
They have funding mechanisms behind this, and these expanded veterans benefits is the third largest. But the key thing there is that there’s no long-term funding mechanism there.
BILMES: Right. The United States has more than 100 trust funds. A trust fund is not a panacea, but it is a requirement to actually begin reckoning with an accrued long-term obligation that the United States has. It’s an existing mechanism for recognizing and beginning to think about financing long-term commitments. And I think what is striking here is that to begin reckoning with this commitment to veterans. And again, this is just the $7.3 trillion is just disability compensation that we’ve already promised.
It’s not even medical care. But if we were, for example, to contribute $1,000 for every American service member who is currently deployed overseas, the initial contribution would be tiny in military terms. It would be about $200 million. And even if we were funding, seeding a trust fund at say four to five billion dollars, which is tiny compared to the administration’s estimate of $47 billion that we have spent in Iran to date, which is a gross underestimate.
But even taking that figure, you’re talking about less than 10%. That would generate $160 to $250 million annually to begin seeding a long-term veteran’s trust fund.
CHAKRABARTI: It’s certainly much more than the zero that’s there now.
BILMES: It is. And it would begin a reckoning, as opposed to the current situation, where we are just facing unlimited borrowing to pay for these already promised obligations to veterans who have already served.
CHAKRABARTI: So we’re putting it on a credit card, essentially.
BILMES: We’re putting this all, like the rest of the wars on this credit card, which as every American knows, is already getting, getting maxed out at very high interest rates.
CHAKRABARTI: This got to a point I was gonna ask you quickly, and then we’re gonna hear from a veteran.
So aagain, to be clear, we’re not saying that veterans are not receiving these benefits now.
BILMES: No.
CHAKRABARTI: But what we’re saying, what you’re saying, is that in the long run, the viability of these expanded vet benefits can come into question because ultimately we’re gonna have to start paying those bills that we’re putting on that credit, on that national credit card.
BILMES: That’s right. But in this case, we’re not even doing the initial work of really estimating when some of these obligations will come due. We’re not even doing the basic work, the accounting work, to be transparent and account for it and try to begin figuring out a way to meet these commitments.
CHAKRABARTI: Even when the number is now over $7 trillion. Okay, we’re gonna come back to this, Linda, but as I promised, we really wanted to hear from a veteran.
BILMES: I did want to point out that 7.3 does not include education benefits, medical benefits. This is just disability compensation that has already been promised.
CHAKRABARTI: Yeah. An important point, and I keep coming back to that number just because it’s hard to wrap my head around. But $7.3 trillion just for promised disability benefits, which is only a slice of the benefits owed to veterans. Okay Kayla Williams is one of those veterans. She served in the Army and was on active duty from 2000 to 2005, including a year-long deployment in Iraq, and that’s where she met her husband.
KAYLA WILLIAMS: When I came home, I was very quickly thrust into a position of caring for my spouse, the man who became my spouse, because he’d been severely wounded.
CHAKRABARTI: Kayla’s husband, Brian, was in Mosul, Iraq, when his military convoy was struck by a roadside bomb. Brian suffered a penetrating traumatic brain injury and subsequently developed PTSD.
Kayla and Brian later married. Life got very busy with work and kids, the kind of normal stresses, which meant that Kayla could not address the traumas she had experienced.
WILLIAMS: And it wasn’t until much later that I realized that ignoring my own issues was not going to magically make them go away, and I needed to actually really invest the time and energy into dealing with my own trauma history and actually do the work.
CHAKRABARTI: That was in 2024, nearly two decades after Kayla left the Army. Kayla says that while in the military, she experienced chronic sexual harassment and unwanted sexual contact, and that exacerbated some childhood traumas. When the effects of that trauma became too hard to ignore, Kayla applied for disability benefits under an official category called Military Sexual Trauma, or MST. She stopped working full-time to get the help she needed.
WILLIAMS: Many of my friends, and I’ve definitely read a lot of stories about people who struggled, but I felt that the process was, compared especially to what I’ve heard from others, both efficient and fair, and I have no complaints about my outcome or the amount of time that it took.
It was hard. It was painful. It was itself somewhat traumatizing to have to go into detail about the worst experiences of my life, both in writing and then again talking to a doctor.
CHAKRABARTI: Kayla received individual therapy and a 12-week evidence-based course of treatment all through the VA. She says she was satisfied with the VA’s care, that is, until her therapist recommended she needed ongoing therapy.
But the VA was not able to just do ongoing therapy. They could only offer specific time-limited courses of treatment, but that she could write a referral for me to get care in the community, that I would be able to go weekly for an entire year. And I was like, “Wait.” VA’s willing to pay for me to get care from somebody in the community that they are unwilling to provide at VA.
CHAKRABARTI: But Kayla did not want to go outside the VA. She preferred VA providers who were trained to work with veterans.
WILLIAMS: VA referred me to community care quite a few years ago, and the community provider that they sent me to, when I had my first appointment with them, asked me, “What is MST?” And I was like, “I’m not going to see you.”
It is not my job to train you on one of the most common trauma sources among women veterans. That’s your job as a therapist to know, and I cannot train you on this.
CHAKRABARTI: Kayla has been able to piece together other veteran services to get the mental health care she needs. She joined a woman veteran support group and uses self-paced at home workbooks all through the VA.
But this is a patchwork, and it’s not the same, she says, as professional therapy.
WILLIAMS: While dealing with my husband’s recovery, I learned a lot about how to navigate these systems of care. I’m pretty tech savvy. I’m able to download the apps and figure things out, and I definitely know people who struggle with figuring out what resources are available and navigate how to access them.
And I can also say that, like, when I have been in my own worst depths of mental health challenges, it is much harder. Like, when depression is severe you’re not going to spend the time to keep following up, right? It’s just too big of a barrier and a burden.
CHAKRABARTI: That’s Kayla Williams. She served in the United States Army and lives in northern Virginia.
I’d like to bring Paul Sullivan into the conversation now. He’s also a veteran of military service. He served as an Army cavalry scout during the 1991 Gulf War. He’s former project manager at the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, and also a former executive director of the veteran advocacy group, Veterans for Common Sense.
Paul, welcome to On Point.
PAUL SULLIVAN: Hello, and thank you.
CHAKRABARTI: Tell me a little bit about what you hear in Kayla’s story in terms of she was able for a time to get the care she needed, but then it got a little more complicated.
SULLIVAN: This is distressing to hear from a veteran that VA was improving in leaps and bounds, as you described, and now there are challenges with what’s called the privatization of VA.
The current Trump administration is moving money from government employees to private sector providers. And as Kayla clearly said, the private sector is often left wanting in their ability to understand the needs of veterans, especially for PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder, and MST, military sexual trauma.
CHAKRABARTI: Now, how do you think that either relates to or exacerbates this bigger issue that we’re talking about with Linda regarding wherever the care is being received there’s still this massive liability that’s totally unfunded in order to keep that care going, these disability benefits specifically, for the many decades that veterans are going to need them?
SULLIVAN: Excellent question. Privatizing VA will make the situation worse. Why? VA care is faster, VA care is better, and VA care is less expensive. Why? Because VA care is provided under one roof. Records aren’t lost. One care provider within VA can see, like a cardiologist can see what a pulmonologist see, can see what a mental health therapist sees, all in one record set where the veteran is getting comprehensive collaborative care, and that’s fantastic.
In contrast, the private sector care is fractured. It’s more expensive. The records have a hard time getting from the private sector back to VA so that a veteran’s primary doctor knows what’s going on with that veteran. So if the current administration, President Trump, and the current Congress, the Republicans, keep privatizing VA, then VA will become slower, more expensive, and harm veterans by not giving the care that they need, and that would be the worst of all possibilities.
CHAKRABARTI: Linda Bilmes, go ahead, jump in here. I would love, want to hear from you.
BILMES: Yeah. I generally agree with Paul that the VA is now accounts for 5% of government spending and has spent a huge amount of money on IT trying to manage the integrate systems with private providers as well as with the military outside of the VA.
And basically, the effort has been very cost ineffective. So there are situations in some parts of the country where it’s hard to find a psychiatric triage nurse for anywhere, where it might make sense to use a provider outside of VA. But the objective should be to fund the VA and take advantage of the efficiencies in the system.
CHAKRABARTI: Yeah. Let me ask you both. There seems to be a lot of, to put it mildly, misalignment here, right? In terms of, Linda, you’ve talked about we’re not even setting aside any money to be able to guarantee these programs long term beyond the credit card payments, or credit card analogy that we have.
And then Paul, you’re talking about there are efficiencies within the VA that aren’t being maximized if services are trying to be punted out to the private sector. But I’m also wondering within VA itself, like can we get an accurate sense as to how much long-term disability benefits are going to cost when, I’m seeing this GAO report from a while ago, GAO report from actually January 2026, that’s when it was released, that said, for example, when VA’s trying to calculate how much earnings might a veteran lose because of their disability, some of the rates that they’re using or some of the rate structures that they’re using, quote “Ratings determinations for all earnings loss calculations remain based on information from 1945.”
Like they just haven’t been updated in 80 years, Linda.
BILMES: I think Paul can speak to the complexity of the system, but I would just point out that the way the system works is that a veteran files for a number of specific conditions. But let’s say that you return from a nine-month deployment in Iran with serious asthma from exposure, and then as you get older, that asthma precipitates more chronic bronchial problems, which then precipitates further problems.
So your level of disability increases, and the compensation that you are eligible for increases. So typically, because of the fact that the system is set up to compensate veterans for anything that happens to them or is aggravated by their service, it grows larger over a period of time.
Part III
CHAKRABARTI: Paul I’ll admit, the more that we laypeople dig into this, the more astounding and hard to believe it becomes, so I want to follow up with you on the question I asked Linda.
So this GAO report from this year, from the beginning of this year it’s all about how the VA goes, has essentially what they call 15 body systems, things like neurological health, respiratory health, things like that, by which they, and the impact of those body systems of injuries or disabilities, and that according to some kind of system they have, they decide here’s how that disability might have an impact on the veteran in the long run.
Here are the losses that they’re going to have in their lives financially. And what I read from this GAO report, it says that those 15 body systems and the data associated with them are undergoing an update at the VA now because most of them date from 1945. So here’s what the GAO report says. It says, “Disability ratings in the rating schedule are primarily based on physicians’ and lawyers’ judgments made over 80 years ago about the effect service connected conditions had on the average individual’s ability to perform jobs.”
And the GAO report says that right now four of those 15 systems have still received no update at all, including veterans’ respiratory systems, their neurological injuries, and the GAO says also for mental disorders. So I’m really focused on how we make good decisions in this country, Paul, and it seems like, again, there’s a misalignment between the information that the VA has to help assign disability benefits and the reality of the disabilities that veterans are experiencing now.
SULLIVAN: Yes, Meghna. 80 years old is distressing. I want to point out Professor Bilmes is correct in what she said. The bottom line is war is expensive or very expensive, as we’re finding out now. To put this in perspective for listeners, our nation has been continually at war since 1990. Whether it was Iraq and Kuwait in ’91, then expanding to Afghanistan, then back to Iraq in 2003, and now we have the new war in Iran, and the entire Southwest Asia or Middle East area has been at war for 35-plus years.
And a lot of unexpected things have happened. For example, who knew U.S. service members would be exposed to sarin chemical warfare agents or mustard gas or burn pit pollution, or in the case of the Vietnam War, Agent Orange, which is a defoliant with toxin, which is dioxin, which is a toxic poison.
And then there’s radiation. Our ammunition is made out of uranium. So the science that’s been developed in the last 40, 50 years regarding these exposures shows a link between these toxins and illnesses in veterans. The prime example is last October, a year ago, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and the World Health Organization for the United Nations agreed that Gulf War illness is real.
What that means is there’s all these toxic exposures, then there’s all these illnesses. The science links the exposures with the illnesses. Then you have millions of veterans who had previously been denied health care benefits, now flooding into VA filing claims. And then, as Professor Bilmes said, war is expensive, and then when we find out more about the war, it becomes very expensive.
CHAKRABARTI: Linda, go ahead. Professor Bilmes.
BILMES: Yeah. I agree with everything Paul’s saying. I guess I just want to keep the focus here on how we spend taxpayer money. The Trump administration has proposed a $1.5 trillion defense plan, including a $350 billion reconciliation bill, which is being debated by the lame duck Congress.
And where is that money going? That money is going for future weapons, for missiles, for drones, for artificial intelligence, for high-tech munitions of various kinds. And the question in my mind as someone who studies how we allocate resources is if we can find hundreds of billions of dollars to fight wars and develop new weapons, we should also be setting aside money to care for the people who fight those wars.
It’s simply irresponsible to be spending all of the money on and borrowing this money to fight the wars without establishing even the basics for a mechanism to take care of those, to pay for taking care of those who we are sending into harm’s way.
CHAKRABARTI: Paul, did you want to add to that? Go ahead.
SULLIVAN: Yes. And in addition to not funding future requirements, there are three threats to the existing system. The first is the Congress in 2025 moving $22 billion for funding that was originally set for government employees to provide medical care over to the private sector.
That’s a huge threat. That’s privatizing VA and taking away the economies of scale and efficiency. And another threat is a bill that will be voted on in the next couple of days called TACAVA, or Taking Care of America’s Veterans Act. That would cut more than $50 billion in future benefits to give a smaller amount of benefits to current veterans.
And then there’s a third threat, and that’s from the private sector for bad actors called claim sharks, who, seeing that VA is paying out about $200 billion or more dollars per year in disability compensation for wounded, injured, and ill, and traumatized veterans, these private companies are breaking the law and stealing about a billion dollars in benefits from the veterans.
So we have no plan for our government to fund VA. At the same time, there are people within the government trying to undermine VA, while at the same time we have people in the private sector, claim sharks or private medical companies trying to make money off veterans. So that’s the big picture that’s going on right now.
CHAKRABARTI: Did you want to say something, Linda?
BILMES: Yeah. I just want to make clear that when people think about the size and the scale of the Department of Veterans Affairs, this is a huge entity and it has grown enormously. There are 450,000 people working there, large budget. There’s a lot of money. But this is like current money. It’s like the money that you spend to pay for your coffee every morning. This is not money that is set aside for long-term obligations. Now, in cities and states, we have long-term capital budgets, so if you’re paying for a bridge, you can pay for it over 30 years. You set aside a financing system to pay over 30 years.
Now here, when we think about paying for wars, we know that there is a long-term obligation. We just finished paying for the last Civil War veteran in 2020. We know there is this long tail. We know it, we can roughly estimate it, and yet we have not done the most basic steps toward setting aside a financing mechanism.
CHAKRABARTI: I want to go into more solutions-oriented conversation just a second, but Linda, you said we just finished paying for the last Civil War veteran in 2020. How is that even possible?
BILMES: We paid for the dependent, the child of a Civil War veteran who passed away in 2020. So this is how long this tail of war costs can continue. So when we think about the fact that we right now have some 50,000 and in total around 80,000 young people, average age 24, deployed on ships, on bases, exposed to a huge amount of toxins in the Iran war, we have to think about the fact that over their lifetime, many of them will come home and they are not the same.
Most young people, as with everything else, don’t stay in the military for a 20-year career, which is what is required in order to have a military pension. So they come home, in most cases, to smaller towns around the country. They notice that their best friend has maybe bought a house. He’s gotten married, maybe has a kid.
They’ve been in the military for a few years and have, in a way, nothing to show for it but a bad knee, a bad back, and PTSD.
CHAKRABARTI: Which stays with them, though, for the rest of their lives.
BILMES: Which stays with them and gets worse. Yeah. And so we have… I see it as not what they deserve, but what they have earned comparable to deferred compensation.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so Linda and Paul, hang on here for just a second because this is a huge topic, but we also just want to briefly touch on something else that veterans have to deal with on the ground as they’re seeking to get these earned benefits, that phrase that you just used, Linda. Because in January of this year, the current secretary of the VA, Doug Collins, told lawmakers that for mental health care, he says wait times have actually gone down. And as of January 21st, the national average for mental health care for new patients is 18.8 days.
The national average for established patients is 5.8 days. John Medve is a retired 24-year Army officer, and he actually went and crunched some numbers himself using public VA Office of Inspector General reports, and he has come to an entirely different conclusion about those wait times than the one provided by Collins.
MEDVE: I find it difficult to reconcile that with two-thirds of patients missing 20-day appointment schedules and the fact that the data behind those averages that the secretary has said has not been released. So we don’t know where he’s pulling that from.
CHAKRABARTI: John worked at the Department of Veterans Affairs for 12 years and now consults on veterans issues.
And he says the VA Office of Inspector General reports show that out of the 142,000 veterans seeking mental health consults in the 2025 fiscal year, more than two-thirds of them were not seen within 20 days, which is the VA’s own standard for patient wait time. And outside the VA, the community care system didn’t perform much better for veterans.
MEDVE: On the community care side, they have an internal standard of seven days to schedule. 80% of 198,000 consults missed that in 2025. The average time to schedule was 31 days.
CHAKRABARTI: And these are, of course, national averages, which obscure some terrible regional variations.
MEDVE: So in Birmingham, Alabama, 16% waited more than 60 days to get an appointment. In Dallas, only 10% were scheduled within seven days, 83% was seen within 30 days and 5% waited more than 61 days. So again, if you’re just looking at national averages, the fact that there are 5% of almost 14,000 consults that are waiting over two months to be seen is not good.
CHAKRABARTI: And again, these are wait times for community care, but which would also eventually still be paid for by the VA. But John says that most veterans he knows, like Kayla Williams, who we heard from earlier, prefer care within the VA system, which itself does not have enough staff to meet that specific demand.
MEDVE: For mental health, of the 134 VA medical centers, 58% of those facilities are reporting that they have a shortage in their psychology department. 54% of those facilities are reporting they have a shortage in psychiatry, and 51% of those facilities are reporting that they have a shortage in social work.
CHAKRABARTI: That’s retired Army officer John Medve. Okay, so Professor Bilmes and Paul Sullivan, we only have a couple of minutes left, and I want to hear more about what do we do about this. And let’s just return our focus, because it’s just, it’s easier to think simply about, Linda, about those that $7.3 trillion currently, that liability for just disability benefits, okay?
So Paul, let me just ask you first, and then I’ll give Linda the last word here. If you could have the administration and Congress do one thing right now to help ensure that we have the funds to continue those disability benefits long-term, what would it be?
SULLIVAN: Great question. The first is to rehire the thousands of VBA claims processors that Collins fired. It’s between 2,000 and 4,000 claims processors were fired. That means that there’s 1.6 million veterans waiting on all types of VA benefits, sometimes for years. So my top wish would be Congress, Secretary Collins, President Trump, hire back the veterans who used to work at VA, about a third of VA staff are veterans.
Start processing those claims so that the veterans can get what they need now to put food on the table and pay the rent. And remember, for a veteran to receive VA care, in most cases, the veteran has to win their claim. So let’s fix the claim problem right away with hiring more staff.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay, Linda, you get the last minute and a half. What should we do?
BILMES: So if we can find hundreds of billions to fight wars and develop new weapons, we should also be setting aside money to care for the people who fight those wars. And my immediate proposal is that we should set aside $1,000 per service member deployed, and this is for future veteran obligations, not paying each veteran $1,000. But setting aside that which would immediately begin to generate several hundred million dollars a year that would be put toward creating a veterans’ benefit trust fund.
Secondly, we should establish a commission to figure out the structure of how a veterans’ trust fund would be set up along the lines of the Military Retirement Trust Fund, which is for those who stay in the military long-term as a career.
This article was originally published on WBUR.org.


