Why so many Americans can’t keep up with their car payments
Americans currently owe more than $1.7 trillion in auto loan debt, and the average monthly payment for a new car recently hit $800 a month. How did the auto loan industry get to this point, and what happens when families can’t pay?
Guests
Angela Hanks, Chief of Policy Programs at the Century Foundation. Co-author of the report “When the Wheels Come Off: How Surging Auto Loan Debt Is Hurting Households.”
Also Featured
Jessica Caldwell, Head of insights for Edmunds.
Michelle Singletary, personal finance columnist at The Washington Post.
Brandon, used car dealer in North Carolina and YouTube creator behind the channel, “Car Questions Answered.”
____
Transcript of Full Broadcast
The version of our broadcast available at the top of this page and via podcast apps is a condensed version of the full show. You can listen to the full, unedited broadcast here:
Part I
MEGHNA CHAKRABARTI: If you’ve bought a car in the last five or six years, you probably experienced some sticker shock.
DEBORAH: Last time I priced a car last year, it was $45,000. I’m not even sure I could get a loan to pay for a new car as a 73-year-old.
CHAKRABARTI: Deborah called us from Austin, Texas. And since last year, the average price of a new car has gone up even higher. It’s now over $51,000, a record high. And monthly payments?
CELESTE: What do you drive, and how much do you pay?
PERSON #1: A 2018 C7 Grand Sport, like $500 bucks.
PERSON #2: I drive a Kia EV6, and my monthly payment is $460.
PERSON #3: I drive a 2019 Chevy Silverado LT, and my monthly payment is $691.
CHAKRABARTI: Those are numbers from TikTok creator Celeste Emmons. And her friends’ car payments, by the way, are below average because the average monthly payment for a new car is now nearly 800 bucks a month. One in five new car buyers actually pay over $1,000 a month, according to Edmunds, the car shopping guide.
Americans now owe $1.7 trillion in auto loan debt. That’s more than the total credit card debt in this country. Nearly 8% of loans are past due by at least one month, and auto loan terms are getting longer. Between two and three million cars were repossessed last year. All signs point to one question. Are we on the edge of a subprime-type auto loan crisis?
Angela Hanks joins us now. She’s former associate director of external affairs at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and now she’s chief of policy programs at the Century Foundation and co-author of a report entitled When the Wheels Come Off: How Surging Auto Loan Debt is Hurting Households.
Angela, welcome to On Point.
ANGELA HANKS: Hi, Meghna. Thanks so much for having me.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so let’s first of all start by going deeper into the numbers. Below that top line of … $1.7 trillion in debt auto loan debt, what else are we seeing? Is it the same everywhere? Is it different across different income brackets? Tell me more.
HANKS: Yeah. So auto debt is widespread. 86 million Americans around the country hold auto debt right now, so that’s about 28% of consumers. And that adds up to $1.7 trillion in total auto debt. We’ve seen a real spike in auto prices over the last several years, from pre-pandemic to now.
And we’ve also seen a rise in interest rates and that’s especially true for consumers who either are low income or have lower credit scores. For those consumers in particular, they’re paying incredibly high interest rates and often higher total amounts per month in their loans than higher income buyers.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so let’s take those one at a time. First of all, just the sheer price. We’ll talk about used cars later, but the sheer price of a new car, that $51,000 average is just mind-boggling actually. You said the pandemic. Is that simply because of the supply chain crunch that we had during the pandemic, not just for cars being imported into the United States, but even for parts?
HANKS: Yeah, so there’s no one single cause of rising auto prices, but there are a few that we can point to, and I would start with the pandemic as a real catalyst for the prices that we’re seeing now. So of course, we all remember during the pandemic we saw really big shocks to supply chains across the globe which resulted in a shortage of many things, including components and cars.
I think semiconductors were the things that people were most used to hearing about, but it extended to many other types of auto parts as well. And that really contributed to a supply crunch in the vehicles that were available for purchase. That also led to a spike in used car prices during that period because there was this supply crunch on the new car market.
And as the kind of supply chain effect subsided we saw a couple of things start to keep prices high. So one, automakers during that period just started to make fewer cars. And the cars that they did make were geared toward higher income consumers. They were really shifting the market to people who could afford to pay more and doing less to cater to people who had less disposable income.
In addition, as we saw interest rates rise, that also contributed to the rising prices that people paid. And frankly, we saw lenders and slow to decelerate the interest rates as interest rates started to go down overall. And then more recently we have the tariffs, which has impacted auto part availability and auto prices themselves in a number of ways. So it’s really a confluence of several events that have led to prices being this high.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay, let me go back to something you just said about lenders decelerating their own interest rates as prime rates maybe eased off a little bit.
So meaning that they just were making a lot of money, so they decided not to relax their own, the interest rates they were charging to people taking on these auto loans. Do we have the same phenomenon in the sheer pricing side from the car manufacturers? Do they have no incentive to actually ease off on prices if they’re still making so much money from those high-end buyers?
HANKS: Yeah, they really shifted to these cars that they found to be more profitable, and then didn’t start making cheap cars again, and also didn’t lower the prices on the ones that exist. And so consumers, the large majority of whom could not afford to pay $51,000 for a new car were stuck in this situation where the reality is, by and large, there are no more cheap cars left for consumers to buy, and interest rates are quite high.
And so what we’ve seen as consumers are trying to cope with this is the rise of the extended-term auto loans. In 2018 —
CHAKRABARTI: Actually, I’m gonna jump in there, Angela. Hang on … because I actually want to spend a lot of time on the finance structure side of things in the next segment, so we’re going to get nerdy about loans in a moment.
But in terms of like the big three drivers of these really high prices for automobiles, I think the second one, or the third one that you mentioned let’s go back to that, and that is since cars are getting more expensive higher income buyers can still weather that cost, which means two things.
One is, as you said, new cars are becoming further out of reach for low-income households, but also, I would imagine, and I think the Century Foundation found this outcome, that the cost of auto payments then is becoming a proportionally higher percentage of household budgets for lower income households.
I see that you say you found that the average auto loan balance for low-income borrowers is nearly $4,000 more than for borrowers in the top income quintile. So it’s like kind of a doubling or tripling of the financial pressure on lower income families.
HANKS: That’s exactly right. And I think it’s important to bear in mind that this isn’t lower income borrowers paying more as a proportion of their income.
This is lower income borrowers paying more outright than higher income borrowers, because they tend to have higher interest rates on the loans that they’re able to obtain. People who have less money in the first place are paying much more both, I would say, out a higher percentage of their income overall is going toward their auto loan payments, and then they’re also just paying more outright than their higher income counterparts.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay. And there’s another interesting thing here that the Century Foundation report found, that there are some states where this auto loan crisis is much more acute than others. I’m seeing here that you have, what, Texas, Alaska, Louisiana, Florida, states like that. What do you think those states have in common?
HANKS: Yeah, one thing they have in common is these are states where you are more likely to need a car. You know, these are not places that have robust public transit infrastructure. They have more rural areas. And so we’re seeing higher balances in places where people are most likely to need a car, so they can’t go without or they can’t go with one per household as compared to some places in more urban areas.
And they’re paying much more to do that. And also, these tend to be in places that where median income is lower too. These are borrowers who have less to be able to afford those monthly payments overall as well.
CHAKRABARTI: So do you think, I’m a little hesitant to say that there’s a auto loan bubble that might pop sometime soon, but then again, looking at the fact that, what, just last year two to three million households had their cars repossessed.
That almost seems like that bubble has, if there’s a bubble, it’s already popped. Is that a unusually high number of repos?
HANKS: Yeah, so we’re looking at the highest number of repos, repossessions, since the Great Recession. And we’re also seeing that car loan delinquencies are at the highest level ever in the New York Fed’s data, which dates back to 2003.
So the thing that is most striking about this is when we look at these numbers, we are not in the Great Recession. We are not in a sort of a widespread financial crisis right now, and these are the types of numbers you would expect to see when the broader economy is experiencing some real challenges.
And so I would say a couple of things are happening here. One our broader research on debt shows that even though we might be in a 4.1% unemployment economy that there is really significant and widespread distress among consumers that often shows up as debt. Auto prices are one acute area for a variety of reasons, including because of auto prices are so high, including because interest rates are high on those loans, the extended terms mean that people are paying for longer.
But this is, I think, a way to understand how the overall economy is maybe less stable than the overall numbers would suggest.
CHAKRABARTI: Let me make an even finer point on that, or a finer question. Because as you said earlier, in this country, in most communities, actually owning a car is quite essential to survival.
So if we have so many people falling behind on their car payments to the point where their cars are being repossessed, usually their car payments is like the last thing that people try or people are willing to not make, right? Because they need their cars. So does this mean that basically it’s an indicator of how much financial stress people are already under if it’s gotten to the point where they can’t make their car payment?
CHAKRABARTI: Yes, absolutely. There’s an adage that you can’t drive your house, but you can sleep in your car, and it’s depressing, but it gets at this idea that people need a car to get to work. A car is often the connection between you and your livelihood, between getting your kids to school, between being able to earn the paycheck in order to make those monthly payments to pay for your home, to pay for groceries and the like.
And it’s certainly a sign of distress that we’re seeing that indicates broader stress in the economy.
Part II
CHAKRABARTI: Today we are talking about a staggering number. It’s $1.7 trillion, and that’s the number of dollars Americans owe on their auto loans. It’s a historic high. It actually happens to be more than we currently own in credit card debt. So we’re asking, how did it get this way?
It’s not just prices of cars. It also has to do with the way cars are financed. Higher interest rates, you heard earlier, longer loan terms. We’re going to talk about trade-in debt. So against all of this is also the fundamental backdrop of the affordability crisis in this country. Jessica Caldwell is head of insights at Edmunds, which tracks vehicle transactions across the United States, and she says the structure of how Americans buy cars is fundamentally changing.
JESSICA CALDWELL: People are trying to figure out how do I fit this in my monthly budget? And that’s where we’ve seen a rise in loan terms, because essentially, what you could have paid off in four or five years before, you’re needing to take six, seven years, maybe even eight years in some cases, to pay off the higher amounts.
Because again, people don’t wanna compromise. They don’t wanna buy less vehicle. They still wanna buy more vehicle. But it seems as if Just taking out a longer loan term is how people are accomplishing that.
CHAKRABARTI: Of course, there’s a catch to those longer terms. Many people don’t want to keep a car for seven years, even though that’s how long their loan may be.
But if they trade it in early, they can find themselves owing more in the loan than the car is worth, and that is called negative equity or underwater ownership. Caldwell says it can follow buyers into their next car purchase.
CALDWELL: The market now is catering towards Americans with higher incomes, higher disposable incomes, and that’s who’s buying new vehicles, and everyone else is left towards the used market or perhaps some of the lower end of the new market, what is available.
But it is a lot less than it used to be. Like, if you look at compact cars or even very small SUVs, there’s just not many for sale as there once was.
CHAKRABARTI: The pressure on inventory is also making it harder to lease a car.
CALDWELL: And as for leasing, we’ve actually seen that dip down over time. Right now, it’s only about 18%, where it’s historically been closer to 30% in many cases.
And what’s happening there is that automakers have reduced their inventory levels, meaning that they don’t make as many cars as they did pre-COVID, and so they’re not in the position where they have to offer as many incentives.
CHAKRABARTI: The inventory squeeze is putting downward pressure on the used car market as well.
YouTube creator Brandon runs a channel called Car Questions Answered. He’s a used car dealer in North Carolina specializing in cars under 5,000 bucks.
BRANDON: Even though I don’t finance at all, I’m getting the runoff of the effect of the whole market, just when I go on the buy side, going to these auctions, seeing repos show up at auction. It’s a big problem, and in my estimation, it’s probably going to get worse.
CHAKRABARTI: If people have negative equity on their old car, they’re not gonna get the benefit of trading it in.
BRANDON: So really, the used car market and the new car market, they all are connected. So the only way that used cars actually enter the system, the used cars that I buy enter the system, is from new car dealers actually taking in trade-ins.
I go to auctions to buy these cars, and the cars that they take in as a trade-in, for me, an example would be, like, a 2005 Toyota Camry, 175,000 miles, something that I’m gonna pay around $2,500 for. I’m gonna sell it for $3,500 bucks. The only way I get that vehicle is if it gets traded in for a new car, say, like a new Camry, at a Toyota dealer, and then that Toyota dealer doesn’t wanna have that 15, 20-year-old cars sitting on their lot.
CHAKRABARTI: So Brandon says it’s not as simple as telling buyers to just opt for a used car if they can’t afford a new one.
There’s just not as many.
BRANDON: And as interest rates go up, and as things become more unaffordable on the new car side, it actually crushes the inventory on the used car side, and it keeps everything crazy high for us, and it’s very hard for us to source our inventory when the owner of that 2005 Camry that I’m looking for right now, when they can’t afford to go get a $750 a month car payment, I think that’s right around the average of what a new car payment is right now, they’re not trading in their car. They can’t afford it.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay. Let’s bring Angela Hanks from the Century Foundation back into the conversation. Angela, I want to actually really go forensically through the financing side of auto loans in this whole next segment here. So let’s start with, I don’t know, maybe a decade ago.
Is that a good period of time to compare what a standard auto loan used to be?
HANKS: Yeah. Our analysis starts in 2018, so we can start there, pre-pandemic.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay. And when someone went to a dealer and they drove a car off the lot, what were some typical loan terms repayment periods, et cetera?
HANKS: Yeah, so prior to the pandemic, we saw a couple of things. We saw shorter loan terms, so we saw more four- or five-year loan terms than we see now. Interest rates were also lower, so the average interest rate at that time was about 7.5%. We’re now at just about 10. And car prices were lower. So people were paying about 10, or auto loans on average were about $10,000 less than they are now.
At every point in the transaction, things were cheaper than they are today.
CHAKRABARTI: Every point, okay. And what about things like fees, like origination fees for the auto loans?
HANKS: Yeah, that’s something that we’ve really seen a rise of in the last few years, is auto dealers tacking on additional fees for a variety of things, from everything from heated seats to additional safety features.
And that’s been something that’s been a newer phenomenon. And in some instances it’s been one that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau or the Federal Trade Commission has taken action on because those fees were illegal in some instances.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay. I really meant it when I said I want to go deep on these loans.
Let’s talk about the terms or the repayment period. As you said, it used to be something like four to five years. Now we’re seeing seven, eight years even. I’ve been hearing about the 100-month car loan. I’m going to give a tip of the hat here to Texas Public Radio because of course cars are really important there, as we said earlier, and they have this great article that kind of outlines what that means for buyers.
So they said if a car costs about $45,000 the average monthly payment over 72 months so that would be five years at 8% interest is about $780 bucks. But when you extend that to 100 months, it lowers the payment to about $613, which is why I think a lot of people are doing this.
It just lowers their monthly payment. But of course, the kicker is it’s adding $5,000 in interest payments for folks. And I’m not sure that a lot of people are thinking that far ahead in terms of the sort, their sort of net cost for these loans.
HANKS: Yeah. I think people are mostly focused on the monthly payments.
The problem when cars become so expensive, both in the sticker price and the interest rates for many consumers, is we all have a finite amount of money every month that we have to pay our bills, and consumers are contesting with having to pay for their housing and their auto loans, credit card debt, student loan debt, a number of other things that make up their monthly budgets.
And so I think often people are going into these transactions really worried about, “How do I get that monthly payment down to a price that I can afford this month?” rather than thinking about what that means over the term of the loan. So really, they are focused on lowering their monthly cost. But what happens, as you said, on the other side of the transaction, is that they’re often paying much more in interest.
The lenders are really making out in this deal because the consumers are doing this because they often need to extend out that monthly payment, but it means that lenders can earn a lot more in interest off of a car, where they used to earn much less if that was a four-year loan, for example.
And so I think people are really stuck in this situation where they find themselves without a choice. And often, those borrowers who are in those seven-year loans are paying quite a significant amount of their income still each month for their car. So we found that those borrowers are still paying nearly one in five of every dollar they earn on their car every month.
So this is really a symptom of a problem that cars are unaffordable. I would also say incomes are too low as part of this, too, but it really is a symptom of kind of broader distress that people are feeling.
CHAKRABARTI: So 20% of the money people are earning can be going to their car payments. Okay. What about this being underwater or negative equity on automobiles? On the one hand, it makes sense because the second you drive a car off the lot, it starts rapidly depreciating. But so is this negative equity problem just a longstanding one and it’s worse now because of the price of cars, or is there something different going on?
HANKS: It’s certainly worse because of the price of cars. As you mentioned, cars depreciate the moment you take them off of the lot, but you’re also driving something that the longer you drive it, the more likely it is that something is going to break or you’re going to need some routine maintenance.
You’re going to have to put money into the car. And as people are stretching out these auto loans, they’re paying for their cars longer, I think trying to hold onto their cars longer, investing money into those cars to keep them running. But ultimately, if your car breaks down or becomes unreliable or requires some maintenance that you find unaffordable, your only option might be to trade in your car for a newer model, regardless of whether you’ve been able to stay above water on the loan.
And so currently, three in 10 trade-ins are underwater by about $7,100 on average, and people are rolling that into the next loan. At the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, where I previously worked, we also found some troubling trends among borrowers who had negative equity on their car.
Those borrowers were more likely to have their accounts assigned to repossession, within two years of securing that new loan. Negative equity borrowers also tended to be consumers who were lower income or had lower credit scores. And then they also had higher monthly payments because they’re rolling over this additional money into the loan.
Yeah. And in an environment where there are no cheap cars, it’s not like you can save on the car price in order to make up for this fact that you’re rolling cash into, or debt into the transaction.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay, I’m a big believer in personal finance education, Angela, so I want to take this down to the level of just understanding really granularly what we mean by negative equity on an automobile.
I’m just gonna make up some numbers here, okay? So say I bought a car for $50,000, right? And I’m on one of those 100-month auto loans. And yet so that’s eight, what? Eight years, right? So but yet after three years, I need to trade it in for whatever reason. Like you said, it just doesn’t work or I want a new car, whatnot.
The problem is that maybe I have only paid off $15,000 of that loan. So I’m doing some math here. So 50 minus 15 is $35,000. So I still owe $35,000 plus interest, but maybe the car itself now is only worth at trade-in let’s call it, $25,000. So what that means is I still, no matter what, I still have a loan of amount of $10,000 that I owe even if I get a new car.
Is that correct?
HANKS: That’s right.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay, so that’s what you mean by rolling it over into the next loan. So people can basically be digging an almost infinite hole of debt that way with their car loans.
HANKS: Effectively, you owe more on the car than what the car is worth, but you need a new car. And so people are in this situation where the only thing to do is to take that amount that they still owe and roll it into the next purchase and finance it and pay interest on that loan now too.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay. Okay. Who are the lenders in this case? I know that sounds like a dumb question, because banks, et cetera, but do the manufacturers themselves play a role here?
I feel like every car maker now has a giant financing arm as well.
HANKS: Yeah, so there are several different types of loans that consumers can purchase. So people maybe are most familiar with you get a loan from your bank or your credit union. But there are many others. Also, when you go into the dealer, often the dealer either has a relationship with a bank or a non-bank lender that they work with.
I will say in that instance, one of the things that has been troubling is sometimes those relationships result in higher interest rates for consumers, because there’s a kickback scheme in play for the lenders and the dealers. And then there’s also the buy here, pay here lenders, which is basically the dealer is the direct lender to your, on your loan.
It can depend on the transaction, but there’s a variety of different options. But some of those, as I mentioned, end up being pricier than consumers for others and sometimes include either hidden fees or costs that consumers can’t see at the point of transaction.
CHAKRABARTI: So you’re saying the dealers are playing a role here.
Do they have any incentive to help consumers lower their costs?
HANKS: I can’t think of one right now, right? I think, I would say of course, they, they want people to come in and buy the cars that they have for sale, and that’s some incentive. However, when you have a market where consumers just have fewer options, it makes it easier to use the one-way ratchet to increase prices rather than lower them.
CHAKRABARTI: Okay. Now, there’s another wrinkle here that really does remind me very much of the 2008 financial crisis. I understand that the U.S. auto loan market is also going through that creative financial engineering of being, the loans are being bundled, securitized, and sold off to institutional investors.
And apparently there’s reporting that it’s a huge market, $127 billion of securitized auto loans. So as delinquencies on these auto loans go up, we said earlier it’s at historic highs now, I’m resurrecting a term from 2008, Angela. Is there potential for any kind of auto loan collapse contagion in the financial sector?
HANKS: I think consumers overall are really at a breaking point right now. We, again, we’re at this moment in the economy where if you look at many of the top-line numbers, you see an economy that by and large looks relatively stable. And I think if you look even a little bit under the hood, you start to see a very different picture, whether it is rising auto loan balances and rising delinquencies, rising credit card balances and rising delinquencies on credit cards, stagnant wages, low stagnant unemployment or employment.
All of these things point to Americans facing a real crisis of affordability, which we’ve heard, of course, again and again both from policymakers and from Americans themselves where the math simply doesn’t add up. And I think one of the things we should always be very curious about in this environment, even when those top-line numbers show us something that looks okay, is to your point, in the 2008 financial crisis, it didn’t appear on the surface as though we were hurtling toward a global economic meltdown, and yet that’s where we found ourselves.
But really, those crises get built over time through practices that are engaged in by financial institutions and other actors to make risky bets in our economy that ultimately leave consumers in worse shape than they were before they started. So I think it’s definitely something to look at.
It’s maybe too soon to say whether we’re at that point of crisis, but I think it’s the right question to be asking at this moment, because we miss those crises when we aren’t asking the questions about how is the financing working, how much risk are investors taking in the economy, and what are we doing for consumers to lower their risk?
Part III
CHAKRABARTI: There’s some really astonishing numbers in Angela’s report. She said earlier, for example, that low-income households on average have an auto loan balance that’s $4,000 higher than for higher income households.
And as with all things in this country, if you’re financially struggling, there’s just layer upon layer of suffering that happens. Because, for example, maybe your credit rating is also not as strong as you want it to be. For borrowers like that, the average percentage rate on a car loan can be more than 18%.
Okay? And Angela’s report says that means a six-year car loan, if that’s you, on a $30,000 car, is going to cost you $20,000 in interest alone. And as we know about the American financial industry, if you are Black, Hispanic, Indigenous, an Alaskan Native, you are very likely to face higher interest rates than white or Asian buyers.
So we turn to Michelle Singletary. She’s the personal finance columnist for The Washington Post and hosts a podcast called Dollars & Sense, and Michelle is also one of what we lovingly call, On Point’s Money Ladies.
MICHELLE SINGLETARY: I see quite a few people who are just overwhelmed with their auto debt, and because of that, they are just paralyzed in terms of their ability to do other things, creating an emergency fund for themselves.
And many times, they have to give up the car. They do self-repossessions. I had a couple who just said, “You know what? Come get the car. We just can’t afford it.” They couldn’t refinance, and it created a big black mark on their credit history.
CHAKRABARTI: So what should people do if they’re already in that situation or if they’re shopping for a car and trying to avoid getting into that situation?
Michelle says you start by figuring out what you can actually afford.
SINGLETARY: And I know that sounds so simple, and people are … “Of course, people do that.” They actually don’t. They feel like they need a car. They go to the dealership, and then the dealership talks about monthly payments, and they don’t look at the totality of the cost.
They don’t look at how much interest they’re going to pay, and then particularly if they’re trading in a car that has old debt on it. But I would just say, when you go, really have in mind what you actually can afford and still have a safety net and be able to save for retirement. So that might mean looking for a less expensive car.
Now, it’s really tough in this car market. The average used car is now approaching $30,000.
CHAKRABARTI: So we all acknowledge that finding an affordable used car is much easier said than done, but Michelle also says there is something you can do. She says do not let your emotions get in the way.
Do your homework first.
SINGLETARY: Before you step foot in a dealer or even if you’re doing a private sale, see what lenders are offering you in terms of a loan, and check credit unions. Credit unions often have lower rates than the traditional big banks. So you wanna do a lot of due diligence before you go looking for a car to make sure you can afford the loan and get the best loan rate.
Really, I say this to people and it sounds so simple, but you have to look at, if I get this car and this car payment, will it give me financial breathing room to do some other things? If my rent goes up, will I be okay with this payment? If I lose my job, how long can I stay in this car loan before things get dicey?
CHAKRABARTI: So that’s Michelle Singletary, personal finance columnist for The Washington Post and host of the Dollars & Sense podcast. Smash subscribe on that podcast wherever you listen. Okay. So Angela, let me ask you. Michelle always talks about personal responsibility when it comes to your finances, and I absolutely agree with her.
I think people are obligated to do their homework, as she said, in terms of figuring out how much you can actually pay monthly, figuring out maybe how long you’re thinking about having the car, shopping around for a loan. Absolutely. Yes, and yes. And at the same time, let me lean on your experience at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Angela, because I wonder, are there questionable loan origination practices happening in the auto loan market [like] what we saw in the early 2000s in housing and mortgages?
HANKS: Yes, there are a lot of questionable and sometimes illegal practices happening in the auto loan market. And frankly, we’re at a disadvantage right now, consumers are, because we’ve lost the cop on the beat as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has really been pulled back from doing its job.
Some of the types of lawsuits that the CFPB has brought in the past was … a lawsuit against the largest subprime lender in the country which it ultimately withdrew from at the beginning of the Trump administration, but 41 state attorneys general a bipartisan group pursued and just won a $700 million settlement.
And in that instance what we saw was a subprime lender that was basically operating a very efficient repossession operation where they would charge people more than they could afford, knowingly, in order to ensure that those people went underwater on their loans that they could repossess and then they could resell those cars again.
CHAKRABARTI: Wait. Hang on, Angela. Can you tell me more about this? Because, so wait, you said the lender was actually charging more, or was it the dealer? Give me the structure of what happens, what happened in this case.
HANKS: Yeah. The lender, which is a company called Credit Acceptance Corporation, which is the largest subprime lender in the country, was targeting a set of buyers who they knew would not ever to be able to repay the loans that they were providing.
And so the way that they were operating is they were using an algorithm to basically say, “How much can we charge these consumers in order to ensure that they will likely default on the loan that we’re selling them?” And then through that they would ensure that the loan would never be repaid and the car would be repossessed.
And the $700 million went toward restitution and debt relief for those borrowers who purchased loans through Credit Acceptance Corporation. And I wish I could say this is an isolated incident in the auto loan market, but between the CFPB and the Federal Trade Commission they really had been spending quite a bit of time cracking down on many unscrupulous practices happening in auto loan markets.
That includes outright discrimination against Black, Hispanic, and Native borrowers. It includes charging illegal junk fees to consumers. The Federal Trade Commission tried to put a rule in place that would actually just allow for some price transparency in the auto loan market, and that was vacated by the Fifth Circuit and not defended by the Trump administration thereafter.
But really this is a market that at multiple levels is rife with practices that are either unfair or illegal that are hurting consumers and driving up prices.
CHAKRABARTI: This sounds so disturbingly familiar, Angela. I just … so that makes me wonder. There’s no CFPB anymore, but there’s still Congress, and do you see the auto loan market as being ripe for some kind of reform?
The kind of reforms that we had in mortgage lending after 2000, 2008, some people think it went too far, but at least there was a greater scrutiny of mortgage applications. There was a clarity and truth in lending laws that went through, right? So that people, at least the pieces of paper that were put in front of them were supposed to be a little more comprehensible in terms of how much you would actually owe.
Are any such regulations in place for the auto loan market? And if not, do you see any possibility that they could be?
HANKS: I think there’s a lot for Congress to do here. So some of what they could do is they can certainly codify some of the efforts that the CFPB and the FTC have been engaged in. So that includes you could pass a law that codifies the CARS Rule so people do have this transparent pricing.
They’re not subject to junk fees or hidden costs when they go to the dealer. There are also a couple of things that sit out of regulating auto markets that would help, too. So for example, we talked in the beginning about the tariffs, steel, aluminum tariffs. Tariffs on Canada still are resulting in higher prices with cars.
That is a power that Congress possesses to control tariffs. They should take advantage of that power and take it back from the executive branch. The other thing is the cost of the car ranges from everything from the price you pay for the car, the price you pay for the loan, to the price you pay once you drive it off of the lot and are using it.
And the other thing that’s really causing consumers to struggle right now is they’re paying this, like you said, $800 a month on average for the loan and then $4 a gallon at the gas pump, and that’s really, the Iran war is both driving up fuel prices, but it’s also helping drive up interest rates as well as the Fed tries to deal with rising costs.
And there’s a number of things that Congress could do here that would lower prices for consumers. And again, I think this is a market that they have to look much more closely at. Because we’re seeing not only practices that we know are illegal under current law that aren’t being enforced by the regular regulators that are supposed to be doing the enforcing, but it’s also a bit of a Wild West and it puts consumers in the situation, to Michelle’s point, where you really have to be incredibly careful about what you’re signing and making sure you’re asking all the right questions and looking out for hidden fees, and it really shouldn’t be that way for consumers.
You should go in, you should have a fair, clear, transparent price. You shouldn’t get gouged on the loan. You shouldn’t get gouged on a loan based on your identity for sure or your income or credit score. And that’s not what’s happening right now, and there’s plenty of space for Congress to step in.
CHAKRABARTI: Every single show we do these days, Angela, about the financial precariousness of Americans comes down to stop the tariffs, stop the war. We should hold up cards, right? People should go to Congress and the White House and just hold up cards. Stop the tariffs. Stop the wars. I mean I’m joking about it, but this is really serious because I also imagine that there are a lot of people out there who are in the upper income brackets who are listening to this and saying just do what Michelle Singletary said and buy a car that you can afford.
Do not spend beyond your means. And again, I have some sympathy for that, but cars are not just of sort of a social, an emotional importance in this country. They’re of practical, survivability importance. But I wonder what you think about people who say just hold out for that used car that you actually can afford that won’t put you underwater in the long run,” Angela.
HANKS: Yeah. I’d say a couple of things. One, I’ll go back to the point I made earlier, which is the reality is there just aren’t cheap cars on the market the way that there used to be a decade ago. And so there are just fewer and fewer options for consumers, even if they’re trying to buy a used car, even if they’re trying to buy one that’s 10 or 15 years old.
The second thing I would say is once you’re in that 10, 15, 20-year-old car market you’re looking at a car that needs a lot of maintenance and might not last very long even if you put a lot into it. And you might have a $5,000 sticker price at the lot, but you could end up putting $5,000, $10,000 into that car just to keep it running.
And people are making rational choices here. They’re trying to balance the need for a car that’s reliable, that can ensure that they get to work on time so they don’t lose their job over not having a car or being late. And they’re also trying to manage their monthly payments.
And so much of what we see in the car market right now is people trying to cope. They’re coping through longer loans. They’re coping through trying to find the cheapest car possible, such that it exists. But really they’re just left with too few options right now.
CHAKRABARTI: And I feel like people are also trying to cope by maybe putting their auto payment on a credit card, which can basically add insult to injury if you’ve got a credit card interest rate that is like 29.99%.
HANKS: One of the signs of distress that we saw is that people who have auto loans are much less, much more likely to hold credit card debt. That’s especially true for lower income borrowers who owe often twice their monthly income in credit card debt in addition to their auto loan. So people are really struggling to make ends meet.
They’re using debt as this means to get by, but really, it’s unsustainable. And the reality is that they’re often doing this because prices have increased, their wages have not increased alongside of that. And there are some things you can’t go without.
You can’t go without food, you can’t go without transportation and people, you can’t go without housing. And people are just trying to figure out how to put all those things together. And unfortunately, policy makers have too often just left them out on their own to figure that out, and often they’re using debt as the way to navigate that.
CHAKRABARTI: Yeah. So I’m looking at your report here, and again, with the continuing train of astonishing numbers here, there’s a graph that shows the quarterly average auto loan in America right now in terms of the auto loan balance is for, yeah, for auto loans, it’s $25,478, which is just a huge number.
But then you also have a graph that says average auto lease balance, which is significantly lower, $13,694. So is this saying that leases have become more attractive, or do we have the same sort of affordability issues if you’re even taking a car lease?
HANKS: Leases have, are not as expensive as car loans, the average debt that people owe.
But they have grown as well over the same period that we’ve seen auto loans grow as well. And obviously, there’s a lot that people are weighing when they decide whether to lease or buy a car, including how long they might have it, what they’re going to use it for, how much mileage they’re going to put on it.
And so it’s not as easy as saying, just move into a lease, because for some people that might not be possible. And with a lease, there’s no period at which you stop paying, right? At least with an auto loan, there’s some hope that at the end of seven years you’ll have paid it off, and I wish that were true for more people than it is, but that’s where we are.
This article was originally published on WBUR.org.


