Easing Up on Low-Level Crimes

The Brian Lehrer Show | Jan 22, 2016

The New York City Council will hear a package of bills Monday that would make summonses for low-level crimes civil - rather than criminal - offenses.

This would give officers the option to charge a person civilly rather than criminally for things like public urination, drinking from an open container in public, and excessive noise. It would not include jumping subway turnstiles.

City Councilmember Rory Lancman (Queens 24th, representing Hillcrest, Briarwood, Kew Gardens Hills and Pomonok) and City Councilmember Vanessa Gibson (Bronx 16th, representing West Bronx, Morrisania, Highbridge, and Melrose), who each sponsored a bill, discuss how the new system would work to unclog the courts and the implications for Broken Windows policing.

As callers began weighing in, it became clear that many were concerned about discriminatory policing. Councilmember Lancman responded:

"81% of all the summonses issued between 2001 and 2013 were to Black and Latino New Yorkers. 90% of all the littering offenses, 93% of all the summonses for spitting. In the 40th precinct in the Bronx, there were 271 summonses issues issued per 100 residents. In the 11th precinct in Bayside Queens, there was 25 per 100 residents summonses issued. This is emblematic of the national conversation we’re having about over-policing communities of color."

.@RoryLancman + @Vanessalgibson say low-level non-violent crimes should be treated as civil offenses, not criminal. pic.twitter.com/9wY5lugcXL
— Brian Lehrer Show (@BrianLehrer) January 22, 2016

@BrianLehrer @NYCCouncil As a public defender I see 8-15 folks in jail every day for a foot on a subway seat, can we add that to the list?
— Michelle McG (@Michelle_Mc_G) January 22, 2016

Civil justice plan for criminal offenses might sound good now, but is going to get hammered next year as a tax on POC @BrianLehrer
— Nick Malinowski (@nwmalinowski) January 22, 2016

@BrianLehrer @RoryLancman @Vanessalgibson this is more court reform than police reform. Crafting it along w/ Bratton & NYPD says it all.
— NYersAgainstBratton (@AGAINSTBRATTON) January 22, 2016

WNYC is funded by sponsors and member donations

WNYC Homepage - Top Stories

Why single domestic violence survivors can't get shelter in NYC despite empty beds

More than half the callers to the city’s domestic violence hotline are single people, but few are getting shelter.

Gothamist |

The History Wars and America at 250, with the Historian Jill Lepore

Three prominent historians discuss a national milestone arriving in the midst of a politically charged conflict over how Americans see the past. It’s a “goat rodeo,” Lepore says.

The New Yorker Radio Hour |

What Péter Magyar's Election in Hungary Says About 'Strongmen' Today

Andrew Marantz talks about the new prime minister of Hungary, and OpenAI's CEO Sam Altman.

The Brian Lehrer Show |

Mayor Mamdani says he's balanced NYC's budget

WNYC News |

How they handle crises in Brownsville, often without police

At least twice a year, nonprofit workers from the neighborhood spend a week calming disputes and responding to most 311 and 911 calls on certain blocks in the neighborhood.