E.J. Dionne's Take on Conservative Mistakes

The Brian Lehrer Show | Jan 19, 2016

"It all started with Goldwater..." That's how E.J. Dionne starts to explain the rise of conservatism and where it went wrong, referring to then-Senator Barry Goldwater's 1964 presidential run that revolutionized the Republican party.

E.J. Dionne, Washington Post political columnist, senior fellow in Governance Studies at the Brookings Institution, government professor at Georgetown University and the author of Why the Right Went Wrong: Conservatism From Goldwater to the Tea Party and Beyond (Simon & Schuster, 2016), says Republicans made an error in adopting Goldwater's approach that reverberates today.

He examines a number of Republican politicians in his book, from Nixon to Reagan to George W. Bush, and the degree to which they appeased and alienated conservatives. "The Tea Party rebellion began quietly during the Bush administration," Dionne says, explaining conservatives thought Bush was too moderate and big-government.

Reflecting on Trump, Dionne sees an important issue emerging that Democrats and Republicans should take seriously:

"What Trump does represent that I think both parties need to pay attention to is a real seething resentment among white working class voters and on the Republican side they voted Republican election after election and received no material benefits out of that. And so oddly this billionaire is leading kind of a class war in the Republican party."

He goes on to explain how progressives should respond to this trend:

"I think we really have to empathize, not denounce, working class people who are going through a lot...Yes, we should denounce racism. Yes, we should denounce the hideous things Trump says about immigrants. But I think we also need to understand that there are rational reasons why people are unhappy and we gotta try to deal with those reasons. "

Now: @EJDionne gives his take on American conservatism and where the right went wrong. Tune in to @WNYC. pic.twitter.com/OrNqQ6nKH0
— Brian Lehrer Show (@BrianLehrer) January 19, 2016

“A party that is so heavily dependent on the votes of older white people has a kind of time limit on it.” @EJDionne on @WNYC
— Brian Lehrer Show (@BrianLehrer) January 19, 2016

.@EJDionne quotes recent @pewresearch study: 60% of Dems prefer politicians who compromise rather than stick to positions, vs 38% of Reps.
— Brian Lehrer Show (@BrianLehrer) January 19, 2016

WNYC is funded by sponsors and member donations

WNYC Homepage - Top Stories

Knicks title run could overlap with World Cup, causing potential headaches at Penn Station

The busy train hub beneath Madison Square Garden could turn into a mess if the region hosts a World Cup and NBA Finals game on the same day.

Gothamist |

Gov. Hochul's Climate Law Rollback

Jon Campbell reports that the state may loosen the emissions goals in the landmark 2019 climate law.

The Brian Lehrer Show |

A Documentary Shadows the U.S. Men's National Soccer Team in the Leadup to the World Cup

All Of It with Alison Stewart |

New Jerseyans who take ADHD meds face a return to pre-pandemic prescription rules

Starting Saturday, people who take medications such as Adderall and Ritalin will again need to see a doctor in person for prescriptions.

WNYC News |

How they handle crises in Brownsville, often without police

At least twice a year, nonprofit workers from the neighborhood spend a week calming disputes and responding to most 311 and 911 calls on certain blocks in the neighborhood.